Discussion: Why isn't P!nk considered the Queen of Pop? - Page 10

EloiseheartsRiRi

Quote:

Originally posted by Liafen

Yet they call Katy the Queen of Pop. AGain, that's what the discussion is about. Why do other, less successful pop stars being called the Queen of Pop but not Pink.

Because whether we like it or not Katy Perry fits the pop culture/music standard. Pink has a general public which likes her but not an obsession as a pop figure.

6_INCH_HEELS

Quote:

Originally posted by EloiseheartsRiRi

Because whether we like it or not Katy Perry fits the pop culture/music standard. Pink has a general public which likes her but not an obsession as a pop figure.

This so called obsession is based off of what exactly? And how is this obsession reflected? What parameters are we basing this obsession off of?

How can everyone else be the QoP except P!nk? I'm really missing this. I know you stated earlier that you think she is missing something, but ALL pop girls are missing at least one key element. Madonna doesn't have it ALL. Mariah doesn't have it ALL. Britney doesn't it have it ALL. Beyonce doesn't have it ALL. Rihanna doesn't have it ALL. I could go on for awhile, sis.

EloiseheartsRiRi

Quote:

Originally posted by AHemsworth

This so called obsession is based off of what exactly? And how is this obsession reflected? What parameters are we basing this obsession off of?

How can everyone else be the QoP except P!nk? I'm really missing this. I know you stated earlier that you think she is missing something, but ALL pop girls are missing at least one key element. Madonna doesn't have it ALL. Mariah doesn't have it ALL. Britney doesn't it have it ALL. Beyonce doesn't have it ALL. Rihanna doesn't have it ALL. I could go on for awhile, sis.

10 pages in and I am really tired.

Whatever Pink is the Queen of Pop if you wanted to hear this. Let's move on.

6_INCH_HEELS

Quote:

Originally posted by EloiseheartsRiRi

10 pages in and I am really tired.

Whatever Pink is the Queen of Pop if you wanted to hear this. Let's move on.

Glad we could come to a nice conclusion!!

I'm like Oprah handing of QoP titles. P!nk, you get a QoP! And Gaga, you get a QoP! And Katy, you get a QoP! QoP for everyone!!

P!nkism

Quote:

Originally posted by AHemsworth

Glad we could come to a nice conclusion!!

I'm like Oprah handing of QoP titles. P!nk, you get a QoP! And Gaga, you get a QoP! And Katy, you get a QoP! QoP for everyone!!

I just CHOKED on my food

You got that hit thread though sis, congrats

slw84

Quote:

Originally posted by vince_martin88

Because she has always been an underdog. Queen of Underdogs

Dark horse...no shade cuz she's in my sig. She just kind of slays low key and comes at the game like a dark horse and kind of wins long-term while others hit highs and lows...she just plays the middle but slays while doing it

Kali.

Idk but she is totally amazing. Actually, let me go put her on my iTunes rn.

Liafen

Quote:

Originally posted by Kali.

Idk but she is totally amazing. Actually, let me go put her on my iTunes rn.

Make sure to purchase her collection of memorable songs, Greatest Hits... So Far!!!

Mariano

It has something to do with her staying under the radar and not being a big celebrity etc.

Anyway she is flawless

BadHabits

Quote:

Originally posted by jackieshann

She's not memorable, does not take risks and is not global enough.

Pink is memorable....the delusion. What the hell?

You clearly don't know what you're on about when you say Pink doesn't take risks. Her first album was Pop-R&B and became a huge success and then did a Pop-Rock album that LA Reid was reluctant about. She gained a huge following with her Pop-R&B debut and was prepared to gamble with that on her Pop-Rock album.

Her songs are dark like 'Just Like A Pill' and 'Who Knew' and she's memorable with her performances, her acrobats and her videos. You didn't just shade one of your faves main influences....

6_INCH_HEELS

Quote:

Originally posted by P!nkism

I just CHOKED on my food

You got that hit thread though sis, congrats

All thanks to P!nk, the Gymnastic, charitable, strong bodied chanteuse!

BadHabits

Quote:

Originally posted by Percivalx

You have Katy Perry in your sig and yet you have the audacity to write this down?

I can't even...

Quote:

All Pink has done for the last 10 years is release the same repetitive generic product. And the worst part is she does all this unknowingly and continues working with Dr Luke/Max Martin and that is why she'll never be a legend.

Katy has released the same or similar type of music Teenage Dream (Roar, Birthday as examples) and she works with the same producers (Dr. Luke and Max Martin).

Last Dr. Luke song: 2005
Last Max Martin song: 2011 - SLY (not even a single)

BlueTimberwolf

Her music is generic popcorn with no lasting impact. All her singles sound the same. No one cites her as an influence. And she doesn't have the stats her peers have.

dfantasy

Quote:

Originally posted by BlueTimberwolf

Her music is generic popcorn with no lasting impact. All her singles sound the same. No one cites her as an influence. And she doesn't have the stats her peers have.

10th page? You're losing your mojo, BTW!

pinktennisfreak

Quote:

Originally posted by BlueTimberwolf

Her music is generic popcorn with no lasting impact. All her singles sound the same. No one cites her as an influence. And she doesn't have the stats her peers have.

Get together! You can do better than this!

BadHabits

Quote:

Originally posted by AHemsworth

This so called obsession is based off of what exactly? And how is this obsession reflected? What parameters are we basing this obsession off of?

How can everyone else be the QoP except P!nk? I'm really missing this. I know you stated earlier that you think she is missing something, but ALL pop girls are missing at least one key element. Madonna doesn't have it ALL. Mariah doesn't have it ALL. Britney doesn't it have it ALL. Beyonce doesn't have it ALL. Rihanna doesn't have it ALL. I could go on for awhile, sis.

Eloise talking crap again?

In their eyes, everyone can be the QoP except Pink despite everyone lacks something...

Quote:

Originally posted by EloiseheartsRiRi

I know you're trolling. But.
Madonna. Bigger albums, bigger songs, bigger tours, more iconic moments, all respected publications call her that way. For starters. And there are many more girls before Pink to even be considered.

Who are these girls?

xxtinaxx

because she is supposed to be the king of pop, but we already got MJ.

j/k. She's good, but not good enough to surpass her peers. Or we can see that she is not phenomenon in the GP's eyes.

BadHabits

Quote:

Originally posted by xxtinaxx

because she is supposed to be the king of pop, but we already got MJ.

j/k. She's good, but not good enough to surpass her peers. Or we can see that she is not phenomenon in the GP's eyes.

Got?
You don't 'got' anything, MJ's gone.

Liafen

Quote:

Originally posted by BlueTimberwolf

Her music is generic popcorn with no lasting impact. All her singles sound the same. No one cites her as an influence. And she doesn't have the stats her peers have.

Quote:

British soul singer Adele considers Pink's performance at Brixton Academy in London as one of "the most defining moments" in her life, saying "It was the Missundaztood record, so I was about 13 or 14. I had never heard, being in the room, someone sing like that live. I remember sort of feeling like I was in a wind tunnel, her voice just hitting me. It was incredible."

Adele is such a no one. Now go back to Sugababes.

P!nkism

Quote:

Originally posted by Liafen

Adele is such a no one. Now go back to Sugababes.

Swift, easy, undeniable clock