[jackieshann]

Originally posted by J a y

1. Get The Party Started
2. There You Go
3. Just Like A Pill
4. Family Portrait
5. Trouble
6. Stupid Girls
7. Who Knew
8. U + Ur Hand
9. Dear Mr. President
10. So What
11. Raise Your Glass
12. ****in' Perfect

Most people would or do know these.

Speak for yourself

The only one I remember is the get the party started song because of the memorable 'im commminngggg up' part. I know Fuqing Perfect as well but I would not call that song memorable, it was just a big hit

[dfantasy]

Originally posted by jackieshann

The hostility

It's the truth. Even Katy has experimented with different sounds like trap with 'Dark Horse'. All Pink has done for the last 10 years is release the same repetitive generic product. And the worst part is she does all this unknowingly and continues working with Dr Luke/Max Martin and that is why she'll never be a legend. Like Cyndi Lauper Pink will be known for her talents and flair and her 1 or 2 memorable hits (whatever her memorable hits are because I can't even remember them)

I would not start an argument with "Even Katy Perry"

[Percivalx]

Originally posted by jackieshann

The hostility

It's the truth. Even Katy has experimented with different sounds like trap with 'Dark Horse'. All Pink has done for the last 10 years is release the same repetitive generic product. And the worst part is she does all this unknowingly and continues working with Dr Luke/Max Martin and that is why she'll never be a legend. Like Cyndi Lauper Pink will be known for her talents and flair and her 1 or 2 memorable hits (whatever her memorable hits are because I can't even remember them)

You have Katy Perry in your sig and yet you have the audacity to write this down?

[accelgors]

Originally posted by EloiseheartsRiRi

Crazy in Love, Single Ladies. Drunk in Love? I guess you would upset the OP with these claims.

single ladies maybe, neither of the others. it's just a fact that very few songs do stand the test of time and they're not usually the kind of songs released by pop girls.

[Mhs90]

It depends on what you value more. Receipts or image/media coverage.

[Superbitch]

Is funny because if you look at her stats and sales bitch has remained unbothered. She continues to sell really good and always gets praise/acclaim. IDK it might be cuz her songs are hits but they're not really memorable? is a funny situation tbh. Receipts are there but she just doesn't feel as big as other gorls.

[TheRoofInhabitant]

Originally posted by P!nkism

Max Martin did only 1 song on her latest album and it wasn't even a single
I don't know about Dr Luke but pretty sure she works with Billy Mann & Butch Walker most

Greg Kursting as well. Thing is they give her the most basic songs of their repertoire, and that might even make a hit, but there's nothing musically interesting. On the other hand P!nk's contribution (melodies and lyrics) are definitely what makes the songs great, but she needs to move on a little in my opinion.

[P!nkism]

Originally posted by jackieshann

Speak for yourself

The only one I remember is the get the party started song because of the memorable 'im commminngggg up' part. I know Fuqing Perfect as well but I would not call that song memorable, it was just a big hit

Which Katy song is memorable though? Coz you are stanning for the DEFFINITION of just big hits

[J a y]

Originally posted by jackieshann

Speak for yourself

The only one I remember is the get the party started song because of the memorable 'im commminngggg up' part. I know Fuqing Perfect as well but I would not call that song memorable, it was just a big hit

Mess. Perhaps some time to appreciate music released before these popfarts took over is required.

[Grenn-O]

Originally posted by dfantasy

I would not start an argument with "Even Katy Perry"

yeah, it's kinda sad... like someone said before, it really does seem like pink was born in the wrong era. or these people here are just too young or too unwilling to listen to her discography and see that she's inspired many of their pop girls.

oh well... whatever, i guess.

[Liafen]

I thought we've got educated by an EDM fan on how ARTPOP is nothing near experimental, but stay on topic.

Originally posted by jackieshann

The hostility

It's the truth. Even Katy has experimented with different sounds like trap with 'Dark Horse'. All Pink has done for the last 10 years is release the same repetitive generic product. And the worst part is she does all this unknowingly and continues working with Dr Luke/Max Martin and that is why she'll never be a legend. Like Cyndi Lauper Pink will be known for her talents and flair and her 1 or 2 memorable hits (whatever her memorable hits are because I can't even remember them)

She never worked with Dr. Luke since 2006, and TTAL has only one Max Martin track, so no. Try again.

[Superbitch]

Maybe is cuz all her singles sounds the same? and always has the same formula?

Generic pop song as first single(peaking really high), second single is always a slow pop rock ballad which peaks in the top 10 but has longevity and sells good. Third single.... idk.

[P!nkism]

Originally posted by TheRoofInhabitant

Greg Kursting as well. Thing is they give her the most basic songs of their repertoire, and that might even make a hit, but there's nothing musically interesting. On the other hand P!nk's contribution (melodies and lyrics) are definitely what makes the songs great, but she needs to move on a little in my opinion.

I totally agree with you, she does need to change the producers, but at the end of the day, her fans enjoy her music, her lyrics are kind of more important to me personally and she delivers them live.
So i don't really care if she releases another album with lead single like So What, then a mid tempo like Try and a ballad like JGMAR

[Beyy]

Originally posted by jackieshann

The hostility

It's the truth. Even Katy has experimented with different sounds like trap with 'Dark Horse'. All Pink has done for the last 10 years is release the same repetitive generic product. And the worst part is she does all this unknowingly and continues working with Dr Luke/Max Martin and that is why she'll never be a legend. Like Cyndi Lauper Pink will be known for her talents and flair and her 1 or 2 memorable hits (whatever her memorable hits are because I can't even remember them)

omg the delusion

'love' makes blind !!!!


Katy won't be known for any of her hits, because she has like 30 hits that are so forgettable. At least P!nk has 3 iconic, memorable hits. Get The Party Started, F**king Perfect, Just Give Me A Reason

[Grenn-O]

Originally posted by Superbitch

Is funny because if you look at her stats and sales bitch has remained unbothered. She continues to sell really good and always gets praise/acclaim. IDK it might be cuz her songs are hits but they're not really memorable? is a funny situation tbh. Receipts are there but she just doesn't feel as big as other gorls.

they are memorable to the GP. but she's not much into media hoe-ing that's why she might not be very relevant to ATRLers.

[jackieshann]

Originally posted by Percivalx

You have Katy Perry in your sig and yet you have the audacity to write this down?

Aren't you a Katy fan? Make up yo mind

Originally posted by P!nkism

Which Katy song is memorable though? Coz you are stanning for the DEFFINITION of just big hits

I Kissed a Girl, Fireworks and maybe Teenage Dream.

And no I stan for Katy because, to me, she's a great singer and I love how lush her falsetto is.

[pinktennisfreak]

Originally posted by jackieshann

The hostility

It's the truth. Even Katy has experimented with different sounds like trap with 'Dark Horse'. All Pink has done for the last 10 years is release the same repetitive generic product. And the worst part is she does all this unknowingly and continues working with Dr Luke/Max Martin and that is why she'll never be a legend. Like Cyndi Lauper Pink will be known for her talents and flair and her 1 or 2 memorable hits (whatever her memorable hits are because I can't even remember them)

She hasn't worked with Gottwald since 2005 and hasn't released a Max Martin song since 2011.

Katy experimented..... Maybe in men, but hardly in music.

Why does her old songs have auch a good recurrent airplay?
If she does the same music, why do anyone buy the same record that many times? Last time I checked TTAL has sold 5,5m albums and 15-20 million singles WW. 15 years into her career.
Why has her GH outsold some albums in the past four years.

Just because you're ignorant, it doesn't mean that there's whole world out there that will always be here for her music and performances.

[alrightsir]

Originally posted by jackieshann

The hostility

It's the truth. Even Katy has experimented with different sounds like trap with 'Dark Horse'. All Pink has done for the last 10 years is release the same repetitive generic product. And the worst part is she does all this unknowingly and continues working with Dr Luke/Max Martin and that is why she'll never be a legend. Like Cyndi Lauper Pink will be known for her talents and flair and her 1 or 2 memorable hits (whatever her memorable hits are because I can't even remember them)

So much denial and so much ignorance.

[swissman]

Originally posted by Truth Teller

Because she isn't.

This really sums it all up.

She is not the Queen of Pop, so how could she be considered that?

Simply having talent, success and appeal does not get you that title or Kelly Clarkson would be the Queen of Pop. You have to have that certain something, the star quality that sets you above the rest. You have to do things truly different not just "alternative" and you have to be a queen to people, not just a great popstar.

[Lein]

Originally posted by jackieshann

The hostility

It's the truth. Even Katy has experimented with different sounds like trap with 'Dark Horse'. All Pink has done for the last 10 years is release the same repetitive generic product. And the worst part is she does all this unknowingly and continues working with Dr Luke/Max Martin and that is why she'll never be a legend. Like Cyndi Lauper Pink will be known for her talents and flair and her 1 or 2 memorable hits (whatever her memorable hits are because I can't even remember them)