[MonstahNL]

Originally posted by love100

only britney spears has hardcore fans because of her personal life and she also appeals to the lovers of generic pop songs ( britney spears = pop music)

gaga hasn't so many die hard fans but she has fans because of the quality of the work

i 'm not bashing britney spears or gaga but while britney spears is (or seems) real Gaga isn't real

gaga is a performer so people can relate to her only for her message or her songs ( same with madonna)
yes she is supersweet with her fans and she is adorable but i think her fans aren't that interesting in gaga personal life ecc,.. they just want good songs with good videos

i hope u can understand. it's so hard for me to explain these concepts

I do think Gaga has some hardcore fans.
But not as much as Britney, I know.

And I agree, it all depends on the quality of the music.

[love100]

Originally posted by MonstahNL

I do think Gaga has some hardcore fans.
But not as much as Britney, I know.

And I agree, it all depends on the quality of the music.

yes. but her fans are fans because of her music or videos or performances

a lot of britney fans would buy everything just because britney is so sweet, she had a breakdown ecc

i don't think gaga fans would still support gaga if her songs sucked. (my opinion)

[Celestial]

Originally posted by MonstahNL

Celestial, how much has The Fame sold in the UK so far?

Do you think it can go 8x platinum?
I'm pretty sure it can.

2250000 copies. Platinum is = 300,000 copies so she will reach 8X platinum. I think it will sell over 2.5 million copies. I'd love for it to sell enough to be certified 9X platinum but I don't think that's realistic. It depends on how many copies it sells during the run up to Xmas.

[MonstahNL]

Originally posted by love100

yes. but her fans are fans because of her music or videos or performances

a lot of britney fans would buy everything just because britney is so sweet, she had a breakdown ecc

i don't think gaga fans would still support gaga if her songs sucked. (my opinion)

Well Gaga hasn't flopped yet, so we just have to wait and see.

[Queen Bea.]

Originally posted by love100

yes. but her fans are fans because of her music or videos or performances

a lot of britney fans would buy everything just because britney is so sweet, she had a breakdown ecc

i don't think gaga fans would still support gaga if her songs sucked. (my opinion)

I think she has also gained a lot of support through her gay rights activism too.

[love100]

^ gaga had always a lot of gay fans and they always supported her..

but i think gaga overestimate her gays fans.. i know a lot of gays who don't like her and a lot of straight guys who actually love her music

gaga is like madonna... she sells only if her songs are good

also her activism is about DADT .. so it's limited to Usa and even though i support gaga and gays and i'm not even sure if i'm against this law

[MonstahNL]

Originally posted by Celestial

2250000 copies. Platinum is = 300,000 copies so she will reach 8X platinum. I think it will sell over 2.5 million copies. I'd love for it to sell enough to be certified 9X platinum but I don't think that's realistic. It depends on how many copies it sells during the run up to Xmas.

Thanks!

So it has to sell another 450,000 copies to be certified 9X platinum.
I doubt it.

[Celestial]

Originally posted by MonstahNL

Thanks!

So she has to sell another 450,000 copies to be certified 9X platinum.
I doubt it.

Sales the week before Xmas are very strong. It's a long shot but she could come close anyway. If she releases her new single before Xmas that is still going to be enough to promote TFM because it is promoting Lady GaGa.

Here's the sales before Xmas last year. http://atrl.net/?p=3296877

[MonstahNL]

Originally posted by Celestial

Sales the week before Xmas are very strong. It's a long shot but she could come close anyway. If she releases her new single before Xmas that is still going to be enough to promote TFM because it is promoting Lady GaGa.

Here's the sales before Xmas last year. http://atrl.net/?p=3296877

I hope it'll get there eventually.

[love100]

would you like gaga to cover a song?



gaga already covered kate bush.. she should cover one of her songs and put it on her album..
she is much more inspired by her than by madonna

[Wilkes]

Originally posted by love100

gaga already covered kate bush.. she should cover one of her songs and put it on her album..

When did she cover kate bush?

[love100]

Originally posted by Haus of Wilke$

When did she cover kate bush?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=03hRtP5fNgc

she did a hood job

[Queen Bea.]

Originally posted by love100

would you like gaga to cover a song?



gaga already covered kate bush.. she should cover one of her songs and put it on her album..
she is much more inspired by her than by madonna

She should never ever put a cover on an album.

[love100]

^ she is so good in the covers ( listen to stand by me)

also i want her to produce all the track without helps

the producers ruin her songs

her version of speechless is >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> the final version

[Wilkes]

Originally posted by love100

^ she is so good in the covers ( listen to stand by me)

also i want her to produce all the track without helps

the producers ruin her songs

her version of speechless is >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> the final version

I think she needs the producers for her big, club-banging tracks but she should produce the ballads.

[love100]

^ i think the only bad romance and pokerface have good productions ( they are basically the same song)

just dance is meh

telephone is crap

lovegame is good

alejandro is a gigantic ace of base rip off


to me paper gangsta and teeth have the best production

[Queen Bea.]

She should do the occasional cover live but part of the appeal of Gaga is that it is all her music, she writes it, she lives it. A cover would not in any way suit her style for a record.

[Queen Bea.]

Originally posted by love100

^ i think the only bad romance and pokerface have good productions ( they are basically the same song)

just dance is meh

telephone is crap

lovegame is good

alejandro is a gigantic ace of base rip off


to me paper gangsta and teeth have the best production

Poker Face and Bad Romance are really different songs.
And in my opinion the production on Lovegame and Telephone are amazing. Alejandro too. Although the Chew Fu remix for Lovegame is better.

[KRL]

Originally posted by love100

^ i think the only bad romance and pokerface have good productions ( they are basically the same song)

just dance is meh

telephone is crap

lovegame is good

alejandro is a gigantic ace of base rip off


to me paper gangsta and teeth have the best production

The whole comment is so wrong I don't even know where to start...

[MonstahNL]

Originally posted by love100

telephone is crap

I think it's amazing.
The instrumental version gives me life.