[Jackson]

Some interesting stats I found while occupying time at work:

-No round was EVER repeated until S4. The first round to ever be repeated was a challenge in which you had to incorporate a specific word into a song.
-The first round to be repeated twice was the ARTPOP round where you write a song inspired by an image/painting
-The ARTPOP challenge was repeated for a 3rd time before any other round was repeated for a second (ARTPOP her impact)
-Only three challenges have been used in 4 seasons: the ARTPOP challenge (4,5,6,7), the Self Portrait Challenge (5,7,8,9), and the Twitter challenge (5,6,8,10).

Percentages of original challenges per season
1: 100%
2: 100%
3: 100%
4: 77%
5: 72%
6: 67%
7: 75%
8: 50%
9: 33%
10: 0%

[Jackson]

Also looking through past challenges, here's a few I'd like to see make a comeback
Vanishing Letter: write a song without using a particular assigned letter (S4)
Fire Island Pansexual: write a song using this Lana Del Rey title generator (S6)
Storytelling: Write a storytelling song (S7)

[beatinglikeadrum]

Originally posted by Jackson

Also looking through past challenges, here's a few I'd like to see make a comeback
Vanishing Letter: write a song without using a particular assigned letter (S4)
Fire Island Pansexual: write a song using this Lana Del Rey title generator (S6)
Storytelling: Write a storytelling song (S7)

No, no,no.

[Jackson]

I know we're both PH family but please vote for me http://atrl.net/?p=37565906

[Cupid]

Originally posted by Moonchild

What'd you think of my song, Cupid?

I think you were my joint highest or 2nd highest score, I really liked it.

Originally posted by Jackson

I don't think pears is lying, especially since knowing I got 2 9.5s it would make sense for me to have gotten a 6.5 and 7.5. But I wouldn't even care about your score if your review was valid, which it wasn't. When you review like 40 songs it makes sense to miss some things in a few songs, so I get that at least. It's the past though

You can't just say something isn't valid because you disagree with it, it's an opinion. Writing is subjective, you only seem to have a problem with the opinions that contradict your own.

I stand by everything I said in my review because it was my opinion at that time, nothing was missed.
I didn't even dislike your song, so i'm sorry if you feel some type of way but it's a game and that's how it goes having different voices on the panel. Maybe next time it'll be a better score.

[Achilles.]

Originally posted by Jackson

Also looking through past challenges, here's a few I'd like to see make a comeback
Vanishing Letter: write a song without using a particular assigned letter (S4)
Fire Island Pansexual: write a song using this Lana Del Rey title generator (S6)
Storytelling: Write a storytelling song (S7)

Not here for the generator at all, but I could make the others work work work work.

[Jackson]

you only seem to have a problem with the opinions that contradict your own.

well yeah, that's like the definition of an opinion. you made some comments on the technical portions of the song as well that are flat out factually wrong, but it doesn't matter. every judge pointed out something they thought i could have done better and i thought "hm, yeah, that makes sense. i'll work on that next time" which is why i tried to cut back on the fancy language and make my imagery more meaningful this round. i know this wasn't a 10/10 song (i gave it a 9/10 where i gave wtmw a 7.5/10)

[Citrus]

Originally posted by Jackson

Also looking through past challenges, here's a few I'd like to see make a comeback
Vanishing Letter: write a song without using a particular assigned letter (S4)
Fire Island Pansexual: write a song using this Lana Del Rey title generator (S6)
Storytelling: Write a storytelling song (S7)

What a great round for last season's winner to guest judge

[Cupid]

Originally posted by Jackson

well yeah, that's like the definition of an opinion. you made some comments on the technical portions of the song as well that are flat out factually wrong, but it doesn't matter. every judge pointed out something they thought i could have done better and i thought "hm, yeah, that makes sense. i'll work on that next time" which is why i tried to cut back on the fancy language and make my imagery more meaningful this round. i know this wasn't a 10/10 song (i gave it a 9/10 where i gave wtmw a 7.5/10)

Jackson - 'Seeps into the cracks of every haven that I find' drag Virginmari. 'Searching for the stars beyond until salvation comes' this line was clunky, fix it fat. No but really, I think it could be a little shorter, it disrupts the flow here. I actually really like the song, the flow and the somewhat imagery, maybe not as much as your song last week, but it's still good. I'm confused which type this is though? Originally I thought psychic because of gods/the mind stuff. But then you said forged and onyx so i'm like okay rock, steel? Idk? The fact I can't work it out kinda speaks that maybe your song isn't portraying the theme in the best way?

Which technical portion is factually wrong? I said a line felt clunky, which is an opinion. I said I couldn't 100% figure out the type and it was a little confusing for me - again, my personal view.

[swiftie13]

Cupid only reviewed batch one right?

[Hugamari]

Shame this wasn't the conspiracy theory round.

[Cupid]

Originally posted by swiftie13

Cupid only reviewed batch one right?

Yup, work is so busy right now coming up to Christmas. I'm gonna try posting some small comments this weekend. I'll be back stronger [on iTunes] next round.

[PhreshDiamond]

ATRL Diamond HIT Presents:

A world exclusive performance


PhreshDiamond



.














Collaborating with, the recently released asylum patient




.




Abyssy












.




COMING SOON to a hit thread near you.

[Hugamari]

yfhdijklmds omg YAAAAAAS I live for this collaboration.

[swiftie13]

Originally posted by Cupid

Yup, work is so busy right now coming up to Christmas. I'm gonna try posting some small comments this weekend. I'll be back stronger [on iTunes] next round.

No worries I understand what it's like being a judge.

[Abyssy]

Originally posted by PhreshDiamond

ATRL Diamond HIT Presents:

A world exclusive performance


PhreshDiamond



.














Collaborating with, the recently released asylum patient




.




Abyssy












.




COMING SOON to a hit thread near you.

I screamed, the shade .

But we're coming to slay, the other girls better watch you. Your wigs are about to be snatched. #Phreshbyss have arrived.



xox

[swiftie13]

Originally posted by Hugamari

yfhdijklmds omg YAAAAAAS I live for this collaboration.

Hugaminho will be iconiK

[swiftie13]

PhreshBussy

[Jackson]

this line was clunky, fix it fat. No but really, I think it could be a little shorter, it disrupts the flow here

making the line shorter would go against the meter (13/13/13/13). you could have said to word the line differently, which moonchild told me to do. but that's not what you said

anyway its my OPINION that you gave me a bad review. doesn't change how i'll use your reviews in the future and it's way too early to tell if i like you as a judge. but even if not that's why we have 4, is it not?

[Cupid]

Originally posted by Jackson

making the line shorter would go against the meter (13/13/13/13). you could have said to word the line differently, which moonchild told me to do. but that's not what you said

anyway its my OPINION that you gave me a bad review. doesn't change how i'll use your reviews in the future and it's way too early to tell if i like you as a judge. but even if not that's why we have 4, is it not?

Just like how you hated me as a member to begin with, before coming around.