[Jimmy.]

Originally posted by Remixed

The most important thing is the praise Gaga herself received, regardless of the not so praiseworthy pilot episode

So do you only care about the positive critics, but the negative ones don't matter?

[Mariano]

Originally posted by Jimmy.

Because it's my understanding that Lady Gaga didn't have a lot of dialogue in the episode.


Also, I haven't actually criticized Lady Gaga's acting anywhere in this thread. I've simply said about the pilot episode being the lowest rated ever, and that Lady Gaga's impact knows no bounds.

Literally EVERY scene with Gaga had dialogue Did you even watch it ? And most of the reviews are saying good things about the episode, Metacritic considers a B review as a 60, when in reality B is at least 70 I mean sis you hate Gaga and you are here talking **** about such a great show (without even watching it) only cuz of Gaga, this is my last post bothering with you.

[Jimmy.]

Originally posted by Nialler

Take the first review on RT and it's already blaming Gaga.



Acting is clearly not for her.

Yikes.

[B'Day]

Please
STOP fighting

[Vespertine]

Originally posted by retromaury

Coven is iconic and it was a pop culture EVENT! Everyone was talking about the Supreme and the witch powers and making memes about it.

This season felt uneventful :/

That was true for like, the first 4-5 episodes. After that everyone complained about how utterly UNINTERESTING the "mystery" of the Supreme was.

AHS is always wildly inconsistent so I'll have to give this season a few episodes to decide if it's any good.

[Dämon]

Originally posted by Jimmy.

So do you only care about the positive critics, but the negative ones don't matter?

You seem to only care about what the negative ones have to say, but not the positive ones, so what is your point? Could you please make your trolling at least entertaining, and actually try, or is that even too hard for you

[Jimmy.]

Originally posted by Mariano

Literally EVERY scene with Gaga had dialogue Did you even watch it ?

I'm simply going with what other people have said on this forum. As I've previously stated in another AHS thread, I have yet to watch the episode. I just don't have the faith considering the comments people have been making regarding Lady Gaga's MAJOR acting debut.

[Nialler]

Originally posted by Tanguy

I think we got your point when you posted that already, like, 3 times before? Are you gonna post in this thread every page, for the sake of it?

We're discussing reviews so unless you want to contribute and stop going off-topic maybe you should leave.

[Jimmy.]

All I did was come in here to discuss the lowest rated pilot ever, and Lady Gaga's impact, and the Little Monsters suddenly attacked me. I don't know why they are so aggressive towards me.

[Dämon]

Originally posted by Nialler

We're discussing reviews so unless you want to contribute and stop going off-topic maybe you should leave.

I'm discussing you saying the same thing 3 times already. It's not off-topic, deal with it, or go back to SYG.

[Nialler]

Originally posted by Tanguy

I'm discussing you saying the same thing 3 times already. It's not off-topic, deal with it, or go back to SYG.

This is the first time I posted that review. If you want to be obsessed with me at least do it right

[halcyonday]

At least it's still 61 on MC.

[Remixed]

Anyways, time to ignore the trolls!



I really loved the pilot, it makes sense why the most prestigious publications like TIME praised it

[Jimmy.]

Originally posted by 2014

In took you like 6 posts to realise this is based only on the pilot. Good for you

I've already stated that in previous posts, though.


I can direct you to them if you're suffering from selective reading, if you like?

[Mariano]

I suggest all of us monsters leave this thread, really. If all of us stop posting here, haters will have to discuss on their own The GP and Critics agree that Gaga was good and overall the reviews are positive and are close to the 2 best seasons Murder House and Asylum. That's the most important thing, now get out of this thread.

[2014]

Originally posted by Jimmy.

I've already stated that in previous posts, though.


I can direct you to them if you're suffering from selective reading, if you like?

Nope. You repeated in every post "the lowest rated season". That was your first post where you used "pilot/episode" instead of "season".

[Dämon]

Originally posted by Nialler

This is the first time I posted that review. If you want to be obsessed with me at least do it right

And this is the 3rd time you posted something for the sake of trolling Gaga. Cut the ********.

[alex_katycat]

Originally posted by Mariano

I suggest all of us monsters leave this thread, really. If all of us stop posting here, haters will have to discuss on their own The GP and Critics agree that Gaga was good and overall the reviews are positive and are close to the 2 best seasons Murder House and Asylum. That's the most important thing, now get out of this thread.

[GypsyLife]

Originally posted by Jimmy.

So do you only care about the positive critics, but the negative ones don't matter?

When the positive ones outweigh the negatives ones, yes (especially for a debut), what’s the point in focusing on the 1 or 2 negatives, unless you are looking for a stick to hit with?

[2014]

Originally posted by Mariano

I suggest all of us monsters leave this thread, really. If all of us stop posting here, haters will have to discuss on their own The GP and Critics agree that Gaga was good and overall the reviews are positive and are close to the 2 best seasons Murder House and Asylum. That's the most important thing, now get out of this thread.

MTE.

I won't post here anymore, until we get some new reviews (postive or negative). We are just feeding the haters with being in here and giving them attention.