[Jimmy.]

Originally posted by Tanguy

6/10 is a positive review.

Not according to the critics, whose opinion far outweighs your own.

[Remixed]

Originally posted by Jimmy.

Have the critical ratings ever been this low, either on MT or RT?


I'm glad you're proud of Gaga, it's the same feeling I had when Nicki announced her comedy based on her life, that she's starring in and executive producing, and when I found out she had a leading role within the Barbershop franchise. So it's good for you to have that happiness for your fave.

I don't care about what your fave is doing

You can stop trolling in this thread though

[Arcane_Sky]

Well, Ryan Murphy's show tend to fizzle out the more season it gets (see Glee).

But still at its lowest rated season though. I don't why I bothered giving this show one last chance, even Gaga can't save it.

[ivi]

i mean coven and freak show are the worst seasons but yet the best reviewed seasons so i don't care what they say.

[Jimmy.]

Originally posted by Remixed

I don't care about what your fave is doing

You can stop trolling in this thread though

Where did I suggest you did? I was simply using my own experience with fave to let you know I understand why you're proud of Lady Gaga.


I'll be sure to see you breaking an ankle to run in those Nicki threads, though.

[Remixed]

Originally posted by Jimmy.

Where did I suggest you did? I was simply using my own experience with fave to let you know I understand why you're proud of Lady Gaga.


I'll be sure to see you breaking an ankle to run in those Nicki threads, though.

You're trying to say that Gaga's "impact!!!" is what led to the bad reviews. I'm sure you know plenty about Gaga's impact, so I'm not sure why you're trying to downplay it in this sense. Acting like slightly lower reviews falls on her, and not the direction/writing of the series which is not her doing, and the departure of the former lead actress of the show

Bye-bye.

[Dämon]

Originally posted by Jimmy.

Not according to the critics, whose opinion far outweighs your own.

6/10 is positive, and I couldn't care less what you or RT think.

[SweetTalker]

The pressed, hypocritical people in here

Congrats to Gaga

[Mariano]

Originally posted by Jimmy.

Well bumping the comment wouldn't make sense, as this isn't about ratings.


Regardless, it's still the lowest rated season EVER, and it's the season with Lady Gaga's debut. Impact.

No it's the lowest rated PILOT episode The season will be great and so will be the ratings, trust me.

[SweetTalker]

Originally posted by Jimmy.

Not according to the critics, whose opinion far outweighs your own.

Bookmarked.

[Mariano]

Originally posted by Jimmy.

Not according to the critics, whose opinion far outweighs your own.

Why are you ignoring the fact that critics think Gaga did a great job (for the most part) then ? If critics are so important to you ? Could u answer me this, please ?

[Jimmy.]

Originally posted by SweetTalker

Bookmarked.

What is a bookmark going to prove in 3 weeks time?


If I were to say "This is going to be the worst and leave viewed and critically panned season ever" then you could bookmark, my comments about the pilot episode wont prove anything, SweetTalker.

[2014]

Originally posted by Mariano

Why are you ignoring the fact that critics think Gaga did a great job (for the most part) then ? If critics are so important to you ? Could u answer me this, please ?

He hasn't read a single review

Posting just based on the title of this thread

Pathetic

[retromaury]

Originally posted by ivi

i mean coven and freak show are the worst seasons but yet the best reviewed seasons so i don't care what they say.

Coven is iconic and it was a pop culture EVENT! Everyone was talking about the Supreme and the witch powers and making memes about it.

This season felt uneventful :/

[Remixed]

The most important thing is the praise Gaga herself received, regardless of the not so praiseworthy pilot episode

[Dämon]

Originally posted by retromaury

Coven is iconic and it was a pop culture EVENT! Everyone was talking about the Supreme and the witch powers and making memes about it.

This season felt uneventful :/

Doesn't change the fact Coven was awful.

[Jimmy.]

Originally posted by Mariano

Why are you ignoring the fact that critics think Gaga did a great job (for the most part) then ? If critics are so important to you ? Could u answer me this, please ?

Because it's my understanding that Lady Gaga didn't have a lot of dialogue in the episode.


Also, I haven't actually criticized Lady Gaga's acting anywhere in this thread. I've simply said about the pilot episode being the lowest rated ever, and that Lady Gaga's impact knows no bounds.

[Nialler]

Take the first review on RT and it's already blaming Gaga.

Hotel" mostly seems to suffer from the takeover by Lady Gaga, whose very presence turns it into a big lurid music video (although one for Marilyn Manson maybe).

Acting is clearly not for her.

[Remixed]

Originally posted by Jimmy.

Because it's my understanding that Lady Gaga didn't have a lot of dialogue in the episode.


Also, I haven't actually criticized Lady Gaga's acting anywhere in this thread. I've simply said about the pilot episode being the lowest rated ever, and that Lady Gaga's impact knows no bounds.

[Dämon]

Originally posted by Nialler

Take the first review on RT and it's already blaming Gaga.



Acting is clearly not for her.

I think we got your point when you posted that already, like, 3 times before? Are you gonna post in this thread every page, for the sake of it?