[Almighty Gaga]

Queen of Pop Mariah.

[kyris89]

Madonna

[DevonDreams]

Mariah

[Frozen99]

Queen of Pop Madonna's >>

Is Borderline a ballad tho?

[Bríseis]

Madonnas by light years and galaxies.

Originally posted by Lamb4life

Frozen >>>>>>>>>>>>> Mariah's discography

This.

[MINKI]

Mariah

[GlitterBitch]

Originally posted by AnotherGagaFan

Wow. You guys think way too highly of Madonna.

Ofc we do she's the Queen of Pop take a seat ''AnotherGagaFan''

[GlitterBitch]

This is really hard both have amazing ballads. But I voted Madonna because while Mariah is famous for her ballads Madonna's ballads have so much emotion and tend to extremely well written. Also, a lot of Madonna's ballads are amongst her best songs imo.

I mean : Borderline, Crazy for you, Live to tell, Oh Father, This Used to Be My Playground, Love Don't Live Here Anymore, I Want You, I'll Remember, Take a Bow, You'll See, Rain, Frozen, I Deserve It, Gone, Nothing Fails, Intervention, X-Static Process, Devil Wouldn't Recognize You, Voices, Masterpiece, Falling Free are masterpieces.

[bowdown]

Mariah and it's not even close

[Altidor]

Originally posted by uwannapieceofmeat

I love both very much, but Madonna! Mariah's ballads are almost always boring and faceless and emotionless. I get a sense of genuine feeling from Madonna's ballads. They sound like they are coming an authentic hurt place. I think Mariah shows her emotions and feelings so much better in her mid-tempos and high-tempo songs. Like, "My All"???? Hellooooo

I wasn't aware that My All was a mid or uptempo song.

[SeanET]

Originally posted by Frozen99

Queen of Pop Madonna's >>

Is Borderline a ballad tho?

my bad...thank you!

[RatedG²]

Borderline is my favorite Madonna song ever but please.

Mariah Carey. Most people on this site are unfamiliar with her discography though so it's not a fair argument

[SelenaTheWinner]

Madonna.

[Hivy]

Mariah By far. My All, Hero, One Sweet Day>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> >

[IMPACTNET.]

Mariah serves better vocals on her ballads, but her ballads are also extremely cliche. I feel more from Madonna's ballads so her. I mean listen to Promise to Try, Oh Father or Mer Girl. Thematically those songs are deeper than any of Mariah's samey love songs. And Borderline is not a ballad lol.

[Buyonce1814]

Originally posted by IMPACTNET.

Mariah serves better vocals on her ballads, but her ballads are also extremely cliche. I feel more from Madonna's ballads so her. I mean listen to Promise to Try, Oh Father or Mer Girl. Thematically those songs are deeper than any of Mariah's samey love songs. Any Borderline is not a ballad lol.

Not just the ballads compared to the other woman

[RickyH.]

Mariah >>> Although Frozen topples some girls' careers.

[dabunique]

Originally posted by Latinazza

I would say that, in general, Madonna's ballads are better (as a whole). Songs like This Used to Be My Playground, Rain, Paradise (Not For Me), Oh Father, I'll Remember, To Have and Not to Hold, Gone, Take a Bow, and many more are seriously beautiful and well written.

Mariah however has three of my favourite ballads: Can't Let Go, Vanishing, and My All.

Yes gawd those are my favorite all time MiMi songs


i obviously voted for da Queen but I wouldn't be pressed if mariah won

[Sissy]

As a lamb I obviously choose Mariah. She and Whitney are the Queens of Ballads.

I like Madonna. I prefer her mid-tempos and up-tempos in general but I love "Frozen" and "Nothing Fails".

I can't at the OP for listing "Devil Wouldn't Recognize You" as a ballad, though

Originally posted by Lamb4life

Frozen >>>>>>>>>>>>> Mariah's discography

Member of the Lambily

You crack me up.

[dabunique]

I jus un-dusted my MiMi collection ... her masterpiece of a first album and Music Box