If you were on X Factor and Britney judged you every week and gave you negative feedback or constructive criticism would you take it seriously?

If she said: "you were off key the entire time, and off rhythm" what would you say?

It depends.

EDIT: NVM, my answer is yes.

Yes, shes been in the industry for years, she knows what shes doing.

She also started out as a decent vocalist.

But this show is about singing, and she hasnt sang live for years.

Yes, I mean, she's at the point in her career where the contestants are trying to get. If she tells you to jump....bitch, ask, "HOW HIGH?"

If she said: "you didnt sound good at all, you were off pitch."

+1

She certainly has the credentials, but we haven't seen the type of advice she gives yet.

if she's limited to "that's cool, you're cool, this is cool" then no .

Yes, why not?

I've never seen Britney really criticizing anybody, but she's known as The Princess Of Pop, that status holds some weight. And after all these years she should know a lot about live performing and connecting with the audience, even if she's not top notch at it in these days. I'd listen.

Edit: I pick the first option in the poll, because it's the closest to my answer.

I don't think she will criticize contestants very much on their singing. She'll probably focus more on presentation and stage presence (x-factor).

The bitch knows who to sell records, do tours, etc with minimal input. Of course I'd ask for some advice!

OHHHHH.... I though you meant if Britney was a contestant
Yes. I will take her seriously for obvious reasons.

Like I sad before, anyone that is not tone deaf can tell when someone is singing bad. Britney knows what she's doing and i would take her seriously if she gave me constructive criticism.

.......

Just because she doesn't "sing live" doesn't mean she can't give criticism
She's been in the music business for so long and her career achievements are amazing, of course I would want her to give me feedback.

And this still doesn't begins. And look at all these threads.