Poll: Would you take Britney seriously as a contestant? - Page 5

brIt-()nstar

Quote:

Originally posted by JClarkSTAN

No one said she hasn't sung a note in her life. I personally would just have a hard time taking advice from someone who hasn't sang live in years and uses a forced baby voice when singing half of her songs in the studio.

BUT. THATS. JUST. ME.

But what does that have to do with being able to tell if someone is flat or pitchy when you can't even belt live after being an artist for 14 years?

jesus christ, stop it.

Not all singers can do a whistle like Mariah can do but that doesn't mean male artists who are judging a tv show contestant in a TV singing show can't hear if the whisting was approriately timed or it was just terribly done. Just stop embarrassing yourself.

brIt-()nstar

Quote:

Originally posted by .::Andreita::.

If is about singing it would be ironic XD...but if is about other things i would take it.

Ironic, isn't it?

JonnyϟLightning

Quote:

Originally posted by JClarkSTAN

LMFAO Once again, Simon and LA, are not actual singers. They did not make millions from "singing". They are respected label producers in the industry and have already proved that they have an ear for talent.

And Britney is a respected artist and already proved she has talent. Your point?

Travis Bickle

If you don't like or hate her, easy you don't see the show, or is it that you don't know to use a ****ing remote control or you don't have one?

JClarkSTAN

Quote:

Originally posted by JonnyϟLightning

And Britney is a respected artist and already proved she has talent. Your point?

This is my last reply because I'm being warned for trolling repeatedly when I was just answering the question to the thread and responding to people quoting me. I never said Britney wasn't talented. Hell, I never even said she couldn't sing. I just said I personally would not take her seriously if I was a contestant and she judged my singing. She can judge my performance all she wants but as for letting me know if I was on key or flat, I just wouldn't take her seriously. That is all.

Nathan's Nicely

Quote:

Originally posted by brIt-()nstar

Ironic, isn't it?

the floacist

Quote:

Originally posted by JClarkSTAN

LMFAO Once again, Simon and LA, are not actual singers. They did not make millions from "singing". They are respected label producers in the industry and have already proved that they have an ear for talent.

How are you so sure?

How did this get a WP?

the floacist

Quote:

Originally posted by Xalric

At least she won't pull a Nicole

What kind of clock?

Beautiful Sinner

Heisenberg

Quote:

Originally posted by Foxaylove

And neither was Ellen, yet no one has a problem with an actress turned talk show host judging a singing competition...

a lot of people had a problem with her being a judge from the day she was announced as one.. even Simon... she was unqualified and was a terrible judge so she was fired

Britney is more comparable to Paula since they are both good performers but weak singers and people didn't seem to have that much of an issue with Paula.

Either way the question the OP asks isn't really relevant because I honestly can't see Britney saying anything constructive, critical or at all useful.