Which of the 4 traditional elements is the most important for life?

water wouldn't it? but you need all

you need air to breathe!

They're all needed. Although I guess that Earth isn't really needed. You could make a town out of docks like in Pokemon Ruby and Sapphire in Hoenn

what kind of ridiculous thread

Water > air > fire > earth. IMO.

well without air we would die right away so air than water

Since the adult human body averaged ~65% water, I ll say water.

Air & water must co-exist to maintain all forms of life. Can't really pick one over the other...

Edit: Come to think of it, the other two are essential too. I can't believe I've wasted time thinking about this

but how would this town be made without earth

it's impossible to pick!!!

You obviously need all.

They used logs and stuff. I know trees can grow when they're underwater. Just like Lima beans can. They'd just swim and float and fish and stuff

Without the sun's fire the Earth's temperature wouldn't even be habitable though, right?

that's earth the water is just on top of it

Fire. Without the sun there would be no life.

Air is not necessary you can just breathe pure oxygen.
Water is not necessary you can just get your water from eating plants etc.
Earth is not necessary we can live on the Moon instead.

Fire

Where's heart?

Voted water but I realise it is air

You die within 6 minutes of lacking air, within a week of lacking water, and if Earth refers to minerals then you are going to die without those soon as well

Fire is nice to cook meat but otherwise is not absolutely necessary for survival

So it would be ok if the sun suddenly disappeared right?

Fire