Thats BS and you know it.

What legacy has she left musically? It's not like trance music took off after Ray of Light. She hopped form one genre to the next her whole career without really leaving an imprint. All she did was encourage future pop girls to use stunts for publicity.

Janet was local so not her. Janet was no one in Asia. Madonna was not popular in Asia either but at least she was more known than Janet here.

Madonna. Janet was local.

Interludes?

Vocal 'stylings', what does that even mean? She only whispered and her vocals had to be dubbed a couple of times on top of each other to make them strong

Janet popularized genres? Please do tell us more.

And those whisper vocals can be found on the albums of Jhene, Britney, Aaliyah, Tinashe, Ciara, FKA Twigs, and countless others. Janet popularized New Jack Swing which dominated the early nineties. The experimentation in her Velvet Rope can still be heard today. And yes Interludes.

Madonna has left little to no musical imprint.

Please do talk about Janet's 'imprint' in musical genres We are discussing pop girls not damn trained classical musicians. Man, ATRL sometimes is so damn extra

Easily Madonna, in every sphere of consideration.

Are they not musicians? Don't get mad Madonna's legacy is getting naughty with crucifixes and wild outfits.

lol no, Teddy Riley and Babyface popularized New Jack Swing. And whispered vocals which is just a nice term for overdubbed vocals due to inadequate vocal power have been a thing since before Janet had made her debut

As a Britney stan, you should give Janet her credit for influencing and inspiring your fave. Oh, and:


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9MLFYa_b38w


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VkCGHfmAwHo



With a lot of help from Control popularizing in mainstream first.

Madonna definitely.

Janet really deserves more credit though. She also made a huge impact on music. It's like her legacy was erased after the Superbowl

Oh My God

Overdubbed or not, her style and vocal inflection was copied by numerous singers. And Madonna's musical legacy is what? They still hasn't been answered four pages in.

Her style came from MJ, it has not been copied by anyone.

Stop responding that troll ex-gaga stan.

Madonna

/end thread

Give yourself a tap on the shoulder for strong creativity!

Madonna has been big in Asia
https://www.youtube.com/results?sear...a+japan&page=1


I see, he left gaga but still holds a grudge against the Queen of Pop