At this point in their career who do you think is the bigger legend? Who do you think will have a LASTING legacy and impact for years to come. Assuming that both have retired let's say at least 30-50 years from now.

Bey.

Xtina. Beyoncé is not a legend.

Xtina. Beyonce is a not legend.

I personally think Christina because her songs has more impact. Beautiful alones trumps any Beyonce song when it comes to legacy. Single Ladies and Crazy in Love were fads of the 2000s. Beautiful is a real classic.

Xtina is called Legend X for a reason.

Xtina.

Neither are legend but Beyoncé is the closest to be one so Beyoncé.Xtina's career was frontloaded.

Are you two, the same person?


Anyway, Bey. Longer career, no true flop eras, better movie star, better in sales and critical acclaim

I'll give Legend X a great chance vocally, but Bey >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

Oh dear, you are so delusional. I had heard "Legend X" so many times before I actually joined Atrl.

Xtina is not a legend. Beyoncé is.

Legend is a bigger Legend.

LOL. Both are legends. After 2020 people would be praising how great they are just like Mariah, Whitney and Madonna.(Even though to a lesser extent)

Some of today's reigning pop stars however....

Dupe much


Aint no legend that cant get a tour off the ground .
that alone puts Bey above the other .