Their new stuff no
But they still have their legacies which arent going anywhere

Of course ATRL has the most stupid standards. Just cuz they're not getting #1s every other year doesnt mean theyre not relevant. Tbh Madonna is here to stay those tour numbers prove it. And MDNA sold more than Warrior, Lotus, etc. so if shes not relevant than neither is Kesha or Christina and anyone who sells less than them. Mariah had a platinum single last year and she has the most memorable voice in the music industry. Shes had TWO songs of the decade. How is that irrelevant

Their legacies will always keep them relevant.

They've reached a point in their career where they don't have to be successful to be relevant anymore, their name alone keeps them relevant. Like with Prince or Cher. It doesn't matter if they don't sell a single copy of their albums from here on out, they'll always be relevant and known.

Yes, of course they are.

Can you name any other artist who's recently gotten their 38th US top ten hit? Perhaps more than one person who's gotten her 8th US #1 album recently? Any other solo artists with a $400m+ tour followed by a $300m+ one, or even any solo tours that have hit $300 million at all?

Madonna is still very much relevant with all her new eras and releases; you don't need to be one of the top album or singles artists in the game to qualify as relevant.

As of right now no. But overall both will always be relevant and remembered.

Madonna releases an album and it's opening week sales match and exceed what the new pop stars are doing today.

Madonna uses the word "Molly" and it creates a world wide scandal.

Madonna goes on SNL this year for 30 seconds and is a WW twitter trend and gains the highest over night ratings they have had besting younger diva lady gaga whom had a full musical shows.

Madonna performs at the superbowl and is the only person to have a half time show gain more viewers than the game itself.

Madonna goes on tour and literally SMASHES all if her contemporaries.

Political activists (Marine le penn) go to a Madonna show, to protest.

Take a look at ATRL right now, what do you see? A thread going OFF because Madonna used the N word.

Mariah Carey does weight loss commercials.

Hasn't had a hit in years

Has a job in reality tv.

Is this even a serious thread?

Nah that's been a thing for 20 years now since MJ performed, but she DOES have the record for that show being the most watched event in US TV history.

Yes.

Madonna maybe, Mariah only in Xmas

OPPPPPPS!

Go back to school to practice your spelling and grammar please. Thank you.

Just Mariah.

They both will forever be. Mariah ruled radio last month as usual, and Madonna is Madonna.

Mariah is.

What?

Madonna is. Mariah is to an extent.