This is from her MOST RECENT concert in Sao Paulo Brazil for the "Dignity World Tour". In light of the recent "news" of her so called "lip-synching" her concerts, this video is proof that Duff really does sing LIVE. She may be slightly off key at the end of the chorus, but I LOVE it! Nobody in their right mind can say this isnt live.
I would embed the video, but it wont let me for some reason. Someone else can in their post if they want.

VIDEO:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qaz_B2lbKB4

desperate?

This hasn't proved one thing to me at all

I think this proves she can't sing live...

JK

Hilary Duff is such a good singer

how? I dont see how it couldnt have proven that she can sing live.

You proved that she can sing passably but not good

lol, if it was live, it was not very demanding

but that song was pretty good actually

We all know she can sing live

^oohh, great choice of a video! she sounds AMAZING in that one.

That's a terrible to post. She's all over the place and not even on key. = /

No, she can't sing live AT ALL. In the AOL Sessions video she is clearly lip-synching the chorus (the hardest part of the song) and in the video from her tour she is singing some verses live but it sounds awful.

And no, I'm not a hater. I love Hilary's music.

Ooohhhh, seems like she really can sing on that AOL session.. well, she wasn't/isn't the best vocalist in the world, but believe me bro, Duff >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Cyrus.

The bridge is live too. It sounds good.

Actually Miley Cyrus singing "All I Want for Christmas Is You" was pretty good.

Please don't remind me of that

I think it's purely live. There's just a backing record or something..

^Of course there is! So that people won't hear how awful her voice is.

You forgot this one, that the same person posted: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZmY4OUDLPSc

You can hear her during the verse & chorus & the "love me, love me" part.

This proves that she is not worthy to have a recording contract she is a very AVERAGE singer.