Like I said, she is not a terrible singer. She is average or maybe slightly above average but not good.

yes it was.

For me Hilary can sing ^_^

Tell us something we don't know.

yeap i agree. And besides, Hilary has never said she has the best voice, nor does she try to push it hard (except for in a couple of songs) so nobody should expect her to sound amazing live. She has a good voice no doubt.