Would "Telephone" have been as successful without teh Quen B?

Y'all make this thread every other month.

I think so, Gaga was in her top game during TFM.

Yeah
maybe even more successful
beyonce's part seems so out of place

It was inspired by the weekly Xtina thread.

B body was the reason all guys saw it

Given how successful that whole entire era was, I would say yes.

I do think the initial pull to Telephone, as well as the video hype, was because of two major artists were together.

So chart wise, no difference. Hype was, difference.

It would've been just as successful. I found Beyonce's part in the song very unnecessary.

I think yes, but the version without B is a little bored, without the 'rap'

Yes.

Equally successful

Please write the title in correct English


And yes, Telephone would probably have been even more successful.

Probably but I enjoy Beyonce on the song

i believe so, its a good song but i love Bey's part

Eh yes/no it's really hard to say because I like the one with her but the one without her is just as fine. Like it sounds too close to compare.

No. Beyonce's verse in Telephone is the best 2nd verse of Gaga songs.

Yes