It wouldn't have been as successful.. the song was always bad tbh

beyonce just kinda gave it a little boost

Yes, and Britney's version would sLAY.

People only paid attention to it because it was a collab with Beyonce and we don't see that often tbh

of course, gaga was at her peak during those times. With or without Bey, the song would still be successful. Look what happened to videophone.

But B made the song a little different from Gaga's song. And it wouldn't have been as hyped. So really no.

telephone was way better without beyonce. i think it wouldve smashed harder tbh

Of course.




The delusion.

It made no difference tbh.

It would've done the same or a tiny bit better. Her part was minor. The song was generic and catchy without her.

Probably would've done the same. Everyone would've still been buzzing from Bad Romance

Telephone would NOT have been as successful without Bey. No matter what the song sounds like, her name alone helped it reach the top of the charts.

Beyonces section does provide a nice interlude in a somewhat dull song. That said though, Gaga was on a huge streak at the time and had just released arguably her most impactful single. So I think the follow up to bad romance would have been a hit regardless.

No.

Beyonce's is the best part, tbh.

me too.

Both of them together made it as popular as it was. beyonce deserves some credit also.

Option 3, tbh.