clearly you are an illiterate in the field of music.
Since when is STRAINING, DODGING and MISSING NOTES is great singing?
Duh! not only Kelly fans are saying that Xtina cannot sing TECHNICALLY correct, it's like a fact to everyone who has KNOWLEDGE in singing.
You don't know it because in your country SHOUTING and SHRIEKING is considered better singing without thinking the proper vocal placement
get back to us when Xtina can sing her songs live the same way she does in recordings
Because she also resorted to vocal training lately due to vocal problems caused by improper singing
omg what type of rock are you living? everything that can u all notice are her mistakes lololol but that fact that she can still sing better than everyone today. And im not that only one who's saying this because the reciepts,critics,rolling stone,legends and casual listeners are with me with this accurate statement.
and how rude of you include of our country for God's sake..****ing racist
While Christina isnt TECHNICALLY perfect, that still doesnt make her a bad singer or make he not being able to sing. She is just a bad vocalist... THATS ALL. Thats one thing about Bey. YES she is a good technical singer, but being so technical doesnt make you a better singer(not vocalist) in some peoples book, because the voice doesnt resonate with them.
I would say Christina has more raw talent than Bey, but Bey is a better vocalist over her because Christina doesnt know how to use her gift. Bey DOES!!
I voted "yes" but I think Xtina should be replaced by some other girl though I don't have an idea who should it be... Maybe Lady Gaga, Pink or even Rihanna.
if Beyonce is this generation then Christina should as well...they both debuted around the same time
Why can't Beyonce be part of the trinity for both generations?
I know she started early, but she still is lasting as good, if not better. She hasn't reached her peak yet. (both in terms of success and vocal ability).
So she could be last generations AND this generation.
I can't really say the same with Xtina though? Idk.
Beyonce and Xtina yes.
Kelly? Sorry, but she's only recognized on ATRL, nowhere else.
Xtina is always cited as one of the best singers of generation, and beyonce as one of the best performers.
Aretha Franklin probably has the greatest voice of all time, and you chose Celine over her
Celine is the more amazing vocalist of either of the two, the only one that can sing good live as in the studio. And her voice appeals to the general public. She is the one whom everyone wants to hear sing on a concert. Mariah's live vocals are nowhere near her studio vocals. She loses all her vocal splendor outside the studio.
Celine is the more amazing vocalist of either of the two, the only one that can sing good live as in the studio. And her voice appeals to the general public. She is the one whom everyone wants to hear sing on a concert. Mariah's live vocals are nowhere near her studio vocals. She loses all her vocal splendor outside the studio.
Lol.
Celine is always lip synching . Celine wishes she had the voices of Mariah and Aretha.
There is no way Christina in her current state could outsing Beyonce or Kelly. She can't even belt above a C5 without it being strained/shouty. That's why she does that annoying lip shaking thing to create "vibrato" with those notes.
1:35 to 1:45
I challenge Xtina stans to find me a performance of her singing a E5 (I believe that was the note) or even a D5 with the clarity, resonance and strength that Kelly had. I don't think you will, because every Christina performance I've seen, she's had to shout her higher notes.
I will admit that Christina's lower range is more impressive than Kelly's.. but she can't translate that to live performances as well as Kelly.
Beyonce is flawless, I'd just wish she were more versatile.
