Kelly's belts have a bit more power than Beyonce's once they get to F5/F#5 and above and are very resonant, that's it. Beyoncé trumps her in everything else.
So many lies in this post. You forgot to mention how Kelly can belt much higher than Beyonce, with the latter having to resort to headvoice which is her only strenght. Head + Melismas.
So many lies in this post. You forgot to mention how Kelly can belt much higher than Beyonce, with the latter having to resort to headvoice which is her only strenght. Head + Melismas.
Well duh! She's a soprano.
Bey can go so much lower.
I cringe when people mention Adele. Adele has a unique voice, that's pretty much it.
The GP would place her there in a heartbeat.
She doesn't have the best technical arsenal, but she emotes well and her chest voice is smoky and full.
Besides, she's actually of this "generation" which is arguably not the for Xtina.
So many lies in this post. You forgot to mention how Kelly can belt much higher than Beyonce, with the latter having to resort to headvoice which is her only strenght. Head + Melismas.
Bey is the more centered(on pitch and on key) in terms of her belts. And is rhythmically better than Kelly. Kelly has the most sincerity when it comes to her tone and has better high belts above F5 though, she gets into the habit of pulling up her larynx. While with C-Tina, I am in a good mood, so let's just say she is better in the studio than in a live setting.
Well duh! She's a soprano.
Bey can go so much lower.
Soprano's are separated from Mezzo's for the reason that they don't have the lower range that the Mezzo's do.
Mezzo's are technically Soprano's with a stronger and lower chest voice thus a lower tessitura. But simply because one isn't a Soprano doesn't mean they can't have a very similar upper range.
Bey is the more centered(on pitch and on key) in terms of her belts. And is rhythmically better than Kelly. Kelly has the most sincerity when it comes to her tone and has better high belts from F5 and up though, she gets into the habit of pulling up her larynx. While with C-Tina, I am a good mood, so let's just say she is better in the studio than in a live setting.
Applause.
But you gotta give credit to Kelly that she is the only one of the few that can belt G5 effortlessly all throughout a song.
Xtina is not an option TECHNICALLY but with her fame and songs, she is put up there too.
Many who are illiterate in music and vocals would be impressed with Xtina. You're right she doesnt hit the notes she does in her recordings. I wonder why does she have to do it when she cannot do it in her live even once
Bey is the more centered(on pitch and on key) in terms of her belts. And is rhythmically better than Kelly. Kelly has the most sincerity when it comes to her tone and has better high belts above F5 though, she gets into the habit of pulling up her larynx. While with C-Tina, I am in a good mood, so let's just say she is better in the studio than in a live setting.
I agree. I guess I did kinda lie when I said headvoice and melismas were Beyonce's only strength, I was a mad.
And for the record: as long as we keep making this same thread twice per day people are gonna keep saying they're overrated vocalists.
looooooooooooolll! im dying @ Kelly Clarkson stans trying to say that Xtina can't sing! Lmaaaaaaaaaaaaao!
bye
CHRISTINA MARIA AGUILERA - a vocal phenomenon that can outsing anyone....what's the point of having a trinity if she can outsing everyone in the game?
True, its funny how when she's sang any little part of a song(on The Voice) of another artist you can't help but notice a big change, like when she did Its going down by Mary j Blige and Single Ladies of Bee.
I wonder why does she have to do it when she cannot do it in her live even once 
