Just like how she got shot down for the nomination for the song "Listen" cause apparently she wrote the least on it. probably a word or two... haha So the other 3 writers of Listen were the only ones nominated.

So now she's claiming she wrote Irreplacable. Ne-Yo was on interview and he says he wrote all the lyrics.. Beyonce just did melodies... mwahahahaha


Here's a link so u can listen to it
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A1P5-fvYglU

the oscar nominations are out?

the song is still nominated but only the 3 writers are awarded with the nod and they excluded beyonce...

Again I ask, are the oscar noms out?

ohhhhh i thought u asked if their nomination was canceled......out.....dropped......

youre asking for the whole oscar noms if its out...... i dont know actually but ive just read articles on the Listen nod controversyyyyyy

sowwwyyy

well until the noms are out I'm not taking that seriously. Perez Hilton said that **** and I failed to see any proof of it. It would be really ****** not to include her in the nomination considering she made the song what it was.

i read it here

http://concreteloop.com/2007/01/beyo...opes-shot-down

LOL mwahahaha...

why she's saying that she wrote the lyrics? I think she wants to be singer songwritter LOL

They first have to submit the songs/movies before the nominations come out. And Beyonce's name is excluded from Listen and the academy has confirmed this.

LOL @ the "irreplaceable" thing with Ne-Yo.

Actually, the 3 songwriter thing is common Oscar knowledge. Beyonce is listed fourth. And a spokesperson for Sasha McBee already released a statement saying Beyonce was not eligible for the Best Song Oscar should it get a nom and was still happy that the song could still get a nod and a win.

Which should then be followed by Beyonce being listed THIRD from this point forward on all future song credits, even when all she does is cross a t.

ROFLMAO.

Seriously, as a fan I can't feel compared to care that she didn't write "Irreplaceable", which was really obvious because Beyonce only has a legitimate 9th grade education, and she's never been a AMAZING songwriter. Let's not forget "Bootylicious"...? I don't care about her losing the Oscar nomination for "Listen" because I'm sure that the most she did was add the vocals to the track, and losing the nomination isn't really a big deal because she's the song's vocalist, so it's like she's still being nominated

But yeah, she should work on being a better liar?

LOL, I look at it as sad Ne-Yo can write perfect women songs.

yall are stupid...beyonce has said on trl, bet, and on her beyonce dvd that neyo wrote irreplaceable and his name is 1st on the writing credits. I would find a youtube video, but since you were so great at findin that neyo youtube video, you find the video im talkin bout to disprove yourself.

Agreed

Oh man, I don't even know what to say, can't say too much or those horrendous STANS are going to go insane. I like Beyonce, she makes good music. But Beyonce has PERFECTED the good girl, hardworking image. She knew damn well she didn't write **** and refused to give Ne-Yo any recognition just so her fans could "connect with her" better. We all know that Beyonce is a hardcore BITCH behind the scenes (Destiny's Child, she gets it from her father! ). Oh man, I'm getting ready to fight an army!

^LOL @ "the army."

My presence & post in this thread alone will get the "Yonka-Elite of Divas" planning their assault on me so I don't really need to say much but you all know what I'm thinking.

i thought the norwegian (LOL) songwriter-team "stargate" wrote irreplacable!?