Both of these bands are fronted by female lead singers that deliver chamber pop infused alt-rock. Both women have big voices. Which is the superior band? Use album sales, music videos, lyrics, or whatever you feel necessary to prove your point.

Evanescence

My Immortal > Florence's career

But i also like Florence. Very Underrated.

WTF? lord.

Florence (infusing the same amount of evidence as everyone else has...)

Evanescence >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

The results

edit : They're good now.

I know, right,? How isnt' Florence winning?

I'm out of my angsty pre-teen phase, so Florence.

Evanescence >>>

I see a certain fanbase trend here....its amazing how rihanna stans turn on their own...sad really.

Due to personal preference Evanescence

Not really familiar with Florence but there's no way they are better than Evanescence and amy lee

Florence + The Machine easily.

I know the OP says "post receipts" but this will be, as is generally the case, a question of personal tastes.

Im am surprised about the closeness of the vote.

EVANESCENCE

The one who actually won the GRAMMY...




PS. I like Florence, though. Especially "Kiss with a Fist"

Evanescence>>>

There are no receipts to post as it's a matter of personal choice.

But Evanescence wins by a very, very large margin for me.

Evanescence OBVIOUSLY!

Florence is boring and had 0 impact.

Evanescence.