[Jotham]

Originally posted by Repo

There's some twitter spoilers out saying that Pete and Grace are attacked in his room and one of them dies and the other lives. And between Grace fighting the RD AND a picture of Pete on the ground seemingly being attacked, seems safe to say these ones are legit . It's also worth noting that there were some major inconsistencies if Grace is the killer, such as how on earth the RD knew to off Chanel #2 in all of three minutes if a Chanel isn't involved, and the show is doing a hell of a job trying to push her these last few episodes rather than keep her a surprise (typically a sign said character is innocent)

I'd say that also makes the Pete is the mall RD theory and just meant to scare the Chanels pretty legit-sounding too. That pretty much means our killer is between #5 and Oberlin. Considering this clip throws a f***load of evidence at #5, it's Oberlin. Especially since literally everything makes more sense with her as the killer.

I hope Chanel isn't the killer though. That would be such a basic ending to the show.

Mess at this Reddit post, they are so extra

Chads lactose intolerance self.ScreamQueensTV

submitted 17 hours ago by 4815162342_not_today

Ever since he said that, it makes me think he killed the ice cream mascot, but I also noticed at one point hester was wearing a shirt with ice cream on it as well. Anyone think the intolerance thing is significant? Also Hester looks like GiGi's daugher

[Repo]

Originally posted by tigerlily13

Maybe when Chad dies Repo's presence in this thread finally will too.

jk bitch

It kinda has, I only came back so I can be bookmarked as calling Chanel when it's her

In all honesty, I'm going in expecting Chad to die so I'm not too disappointed. I'm just hoping either he or Pete lives, since they're the only two I'm rooting for who stand a chance (I love 5, 6, and Cathy more than Pete, but I just don't see it)

Originally posted by Jotham

I hope Chanel isn't the killer though. That would be such a basic ending to the show.

She is, she'll get away with it, and next year will be homaging Sleepaway Camp.

[Mellark]

Let's remember, Sam said "I knew it, I knew it was you."

Just remember, that I might be possibly be Chanel #3

[itsaphrodisi]

Originally posted by tigerlily13

Maybe when Chad dies Repo's presence in this thread finally will too.


jk bitch

were you really?

[Jessie Mulay]

Reddit thinks the maid from 1995 isn't Ms. Bean.

[chris1991]

Originally posted by Repo

There's some twitter spoilers out saying that Pete and Grace are attacked in his room and one of them dies and the other lives. And between Grace fighting the RD AND a picture of Pete on the ground seemingly being attacked, seems safe to say these ones are legit . It's also worth noting that there were some major inconsistencies if Grace is the killer, such as how on earth the RD knew to off Chanel #2 in all of three minutes if a Chanel isn't involved, and the show is doing a hell of a job trying to push her these last few episodes rather than keep her a surprise (typically a sign said character is innocent)

I'd say that also makes the Pete is the mall RD theory and just meant to scare the Chanels pretty legit-sounding too. That pretty much means our killer is between #5 and Oberlin. Considering this clip throws a f***load of evidence at #5, it's Oberlin. Especially since literally everything makes more sense with her as the killer.

Its not Chanel. It isn't any of them for that matter. Unless one of them hired a "forth" red devil on craigslist, ebay or something to throw everyone off during the mall scene.

[C/H/A/N/E/L]

Originally posted by Repo

You're not using my logic. My logic is: Ryan Murphy is on his knees begging the audience to think it's Grace, posting redherrings online, having Skylar post redherrings on line, and throwing red herrings into the show. And I can objectively point to these.

On the other hand, Chanel is one of the few people with.. BIG SHOCKER, absolutely. No. Red. Herrings. All. Season. Same rule for the killer in Harper's Island and Scream MTV. Same rule here. Ryan is doing everything to deflect, including deleting a text in Episode 1. And the only reason you try to deflect attention? When it's the killer.

nn But Ryan hasn't been doing ANYTHING trying to make it obvious. Everyone just jumped on the bandwagon recently and decided it was Grace. It's the same every week. We think it's someone different. It's not that the show's doing it to be a red herring; it's just that we over-analyze to the point where EVERYTHING becomes obvious. Outside of ATRL, SOME Reddit threads and maybe 2 IMDb threads, NO one things it's Grace. The GP would be shocked.

And aside from that, this is a whodunnit. Not some twisted horror movie. It's not supposed to be some massive shock that shows up with some grandeur as if "LOOK, GUYS. SURPRISE. IT'S THIS PERSON." Every week, we get more clues as to who it is and who it isn't. And while we tend to interpret them differently, it's all going to make sense. And the only way it's GOING to make sense is if it's Grace.

[Mellark]

Originally posted by Jessie Mulay

Reddit thinks the maid from 1995 isn't Ms. Bean.

The reach.

[Jessie Mulay]

Originally posted by Mellark

Let's remember, Sam said "I knew it, I knew it was you."

Just remember, that I might be possibly be Chanel #3

Not after she said Boone is a ghost

But to be fair she along with Grace are the only ones who've never been attacked.

Edit: wait nvm she got attacked last episode

[C/H/A/N/E/L]

Alright, you know what?

THERE IS NO ****ING KILLER.

It's everyone.

It's no one.

It's Chanel #2.

Boone is actually Chad.

Cathy killed Ms. Bean.

Earl Grey killed Sam.

Chanel is a figment of Chanel #5's imagination.

I QUIT.

[Repo]

Originally posted by tigerlily13

Repo, sis.The only reason you think Chanel is the killer is because you want her to be. The only reason you ever think anything is going to happen in this show is because you want it to happen, just like you think Chad's the most well-received character or that Denise has more haters than lovers or anything else you've said.

Woo! Not even a page in and I've got personal attacks-

1. My dream killer is #5. Ideally killing O. There is a 0% chance of that
2. O is probably the killer I want least for how obvious she is. I just think it's her
3. My theory involves O living. Seeing as I think she sucks writingwise, I obviously don't want her to
4. I said Chad is among the, like, top 5 most popular characters. Which is pretty fair. I've said I consider Cathy most popular. Chanel #3 is probably second. Then I'd probably say Chad and Gigi.
5. I said Denise has some haters, not more haters than fans (obviously not)

So.. you're just wrong on every level.

[Silence.]

Chanel isn't the killer. It'd be a waste of a character. The only way possible for her to be the killer is if she frames someone else and continues to go on to live her life. Ryan isn't going to waste the character or the biggest star, especially not on the first season.

Also the show is about subverting stereotypes, of course the head bitch isn't going to be the killer or the one to die.

[Jessie Mulay]

You've said you've quit and had this meltdown like TEN times.

Are you for real this time?

[Dylangaga]

Grace will either end up the John of this season or remain the WIll Drake...

[Silence.]

Predatory Lez might've just recognised Boone. Zayday knew him as did Jennifer.

[chris1991]

Originally posted by C/H/A/N/E/L

Alright, you know what?

THERE IS NO ****ING KILLER.

It's everyone.

It's no one.

It's Chanel #2.

Boone is actually Chad.

Cathy killed Ms. Bean.

Earl Grey killed Sam.

Chanel is a figment of Chanel #5's imagination.

I QUIT.

I'm sticking to my theory that #5 is the Killer. The episode were Earl died cemented that theory.

Plus i've had my eye on the Bitch since the first episode. Its her.

wait
Gigi hired Denise. It has got to be Denise.
Denise is obvi working for Gigi. Ohp there it is.

[C/H/A/N/E/L]

2. O is probably the killer I want least for how obvious she is. I just think it's her

Didn't you just say that when it's obvious, it means it's not them?

[Teneo]

KTT is the purgatory and all of the characters are dead and trying to pay for the sins they made in their past lifes, the Red Devil is just a physical manifestation of redemption.

[MattyTacos]

Originally posted by tigerlily13

Repo, sis.The only reason you think Chanel is the killer is because you want her to be. The only reason you ever think anything is going to happen in this show is because you want it to happen, just like you think Chad's the most well-received character or that Denise has more haters than lovers or anything else you've said.

[XtinaPanicGodney]

OMG Repo's back? Finally. I missed ha.