[Bathomet]

Originally posted by HollywoodForever

I apparently missed something big, because last I checked there were only 50 US States.

50 + 2 remix for the jurisdictions: Washington DC Gurls and Puerto Rican Gurls.
srly I dont give a **** how many states are in the US I dont live there. Discussing about the number of states is not the point of this thread.

[Hollywood.]

Originally posted by thegmangrant

Oh my God, that's why I'm bringing this up here! For all the GaGa stans that bashed Katy yet Gaga is releasing 50 versions of her song to give it a boost on the charts.

NONE of them are going to much to the sales anyways, I don't even see any of them reach the top 200 on itunes.

[Anthagio]

Originally posted by thegmangrant

Oh my God, that's why I'm bringing this up here! For all the GaGa stans that bashed Katy yet Gaga is releasing 50 versions of her song to give it a boost on the charts.

Omg. You don't ****ing get it. It's not going to help sales. People will buy their state's version instead of the original version, so it's not like they're going to buy two copies of the song. However, with remixes, they're COMPLETELY different songs, so people buy both versions.

This is not rocket science.

I can't even believe Katy stans have the audacity to talk about this.

[thegmangrant]

Originally posted by Rainbows

I must be a dumbass as well as the rest of the people who love their state + are excited to hear it in "You and I."

The delusion kills me.

[iHooker]

Promo at its best.

[Bad Wolf]

Originally posted by thegmangrant

The delusion kills me.

HOW am I delusional if I'd like to hear "You and I" with my homestate instead of Nebraska over and over?

Who seriously gives a **** about Nebraska? Of course we want to hear other versions.

[Anthagio]

Originally posted by Rainbows

HOW am I delusional if I'd like to hear "You and I" with my homestate instead of Nebraska over and over?

Who seriously gives a **** about Nebraska? Of course we want to hear other versions.

No reason to try and reason with these trolls. We are right and they are wrong. Let them be pressed.

[thegmangrant]

Originally posted by HollywoodForever

NONE of them are going to much to the sales anyways, I don't even see any of them reach the top 200 on itunes.

Originally posted by Anthagio

Omg. You don't ****ing get it. It's not going to help sales. People will buy their state's version instead of the original version, so it's not like they're going to buy two copies of the song. However, with remixes, they're COMPLETELY different songs, so people buy both versions.

This is not rocket science.

I can't even believe Katy stans have the audacity to talk about this.

50 versions add up.

[Boop]

Originally posted by thegmangrant

The delusion kills me.

The delusion of Rainbows? ahaha really? Is HE the delusional one in this thread? you gotta be kidding me

[Я×R]

Originally posted by Riverwide

Hilarious to hear people in here talk about GaGa being "desperate" for changing one word, when their own favourites have all recorded utterly desperate, cheap, tacky last-minute remixes to force their latest flimsy pop drivel to #1.

The hypocrisy!

changing one word 50 times Katy and Rihanna didn't even bother to re-record vocals for their remixes they left the dirty job in hands of the producers and the featured artists

[Riverwide]

Originally posted by thegmangrant

Oh my God, that's why I'm bringing this up here! For all the GaGa stans that bashed Katy yet Gaga is releasing 50 versions of her song to give it a boost on the charts.

Changing one word isn't the same as roping in another artist on a **** remix to help flog your own song.

[thegmangrant]

Originally posted by Rainbows

HOW am I delusional if I'd like to hear "You and I" with my homestate instead of Nebraska over and over?

Who seriously gives a **** about Nebraska? Of course we want to hear other versions.

Please I know none of you were even thinking about this until it was announced. Go ahead and follow Mother Monster mindlessly though.


Nebraska in You And I>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>the rest of the states. And I don't even live there

[Allstar]

Originally posted by Rigged

changing one word 50 times Katy and Rihanna didn't even bother to re-record vocals for their remixes they left the dirty job on hands of the producers and the featured artists

Only proves the point, that Gaga is working hard for her success and is doing it with passion.

[effie593]

Originally posted by Rainbows

HOW am I delusional if I'd like to hear "You and I" with my homestate instead of Nebraska over and over?

Who seriously gives a **** about Nebraska? Of course we want to hear other versions.

dont worry, i would love to hear an australian version. im actually quite jealous and its not delusional at all.

anyway, excellent idea and no it isnt anything like katy.

[Bad Wolf]

Originally posted by thegmangrant

Please I know none of you were even thinking about this until it was announced. Go ahead and follow Mother Monster mindlessly though.


Nebraska in You And I>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>the rest of the states. And I don't even live there

Would you please quit acting like your opinion is all-knowing?



For your information, I've always sang "You and I" with West Virginia instead of Nebraska, because it IS my state.

Check out this tweet. [Yes, the date proves it WAS before announced]

I guess I'm "mindlessly following" though.

[Bathomet]

Originally posted by Anthagio

Omg. You don't ****ing get it. It's not going to help sales. People will buy their state's version instead of the original version, so it's not like they're going to buy two copies of the song. However, with remixes, they're COMPLETELY different songs, so people buy both versions.

This is not rocket science.

I can't even believe Katy stans have the audacity to talk about this.

The remixes are likely to get more airplay & buzz, so it means more sales. Why would her label wasting its money on something which wont do **** for the song?

Originally posted by Anthagio

No reason to try and reason with these trolls. We are right and they are wrong. Let them be pressed.

you talking about trolls

[☈evolusion]

I'd be very pissed if my radio station started to playing this...

instead of the original version. Even if I were from Florida. This is so stupid and unnecessary.

[thegmangrant]

Originally posted by Rainbows

Would you please quit acting like your opinion is all-knowing?



For your information, I've always sang "You and I" with West Virginia instead of Nebraska, because it IS my state.

Check out this tweet. [Yes, the date proves it WAS before announced]

I guess I'm "mindlessly following" though.

Please, you all act like this is something that was very anticipated. The irony of this is that the rest of you Gaga stans are acting like your opinion is the most important.

So whatever this has turned into is irrelevant. The point is that this is a desperate move on Gaga/her team's part, and is no different than a remix seeing as there will be now 50 freaking versions floating around

[thegmangrant]

I'm done here. I've made my points. Sometimes stans need to realize that they don't have to defend Gaga's every marketing move, because sometimes they are retarded.

"You and I" is genius and excellent as it is. Nebraska is what made the video epic. Not Florida. Not New York. Not California. Not West Virginia, etc.




And don't take me as a Gaga hater. I just criticize this marketing move. I would hate to have a grudge held by you guys over something small like a certain other stanbase

[Bad Wolf]

Originally posted by thegmangrant

Please, you all act like this is something that was very anticipated. The irony of this is that the rest of you Gaga stans are acting like your opinion is the most important.

So whatever this has turned into is irrelevant. The point is that this is a desperate move on Gaga/her team's part, and is no different than a remix seeing as there will be now 50 freaking versions floating around

I'm not acting as if it was anticipated.

If anything I dreamed of this happening.

The point is that it's not desperate if you change one word + only the people in their state will be downloading their respective state versions of the song.

The general public will still be buying the original version of the song with Nebraska in it.

Those who buy a different version will be paying money to hear a different word. Period.

Why are you so frustrated?

Originally posted by thegmangrant

I'm done here. I've made my points. Sometimes stans need to realize that they don't have to defend Gaga's every marketing move, because sometimes they are retarded.

"You and I" is genius and excellent as it is. Nebraska is what made the video epic. Not Florida. Not New York. Not California. Not West Virginia, etc.

I don't think you've made any points successfully.

Retarded isn't a nice word.

"You and I" is genius + excellent and will be even more exciting to hear with our respective states instead of Nebraska.

Goodbye!