Oh so now the criteria has been changes to girls that have big sales that write for other girls with big sales; but only their song credits count if it was after they became famous Should fix that OP up to so its not so deceptive
But Gaga still wins even with these random criteria (made to exclude Sia apparently ). JLO, TLC, Britney & Beyonce have sold 100s of millions of records/albums combined. More than Selena & Iggy at least (Katys girls). So yeah /end thread
All the main pop girls have 5M+ selling albums worldwide. Sia has none.
All the main pop girls have multiple Top 10 hits in the US and worldwide. Sia has one hit.
All the main pop girls have multiple AMAs, VMAs, EMAs, BRITs, etc. Sia has one VMA.
All the main pop girl have multiple platinum selling albums in the US. Sia doesn't even have a gold albums.
All the main pop girls have had cultural impact and are important figures in the media.
All the main pop girls are huge on social media. Sia isn't.
All the main pop girls have successful +100M tours or just successful tours. Sia never toured.
All the main pop girls have huge fanbases. Sia has a very small fanbase or just non-existent.
So to be a main pop girl you need to have an active base on ATRL?
Congrats to Katy having an active base on ATRL.net and for writing songs for multiple artists who happen to have an active fan base in the Base section of ATRL.net
Why is ezra making up random criteria to include Gaga? Gaga has only written for Britney out of the main pop girls, Katy has written for Britney and Nicki. It's not that complicated
All the main pop girls have 5M+ selling albums worldwide. Sia has none.
All the main pop girls have multiple Top 10 hits in the US and worldwide. Sia has one hit.
All the main pop girls have multiple AMAs, VMAs, EMAs, BRITs, etc. Sia has one VMA.
All the main pop girl have multiple platinum selling albums in the US. Sia doesn't even have a gold albums.
All the main pop girls have had cultural impact and are important figures in the media.
All the main pop girls are huge on social media. Sia isn't.
All the main pop girls have successful +100M tours or just successful tours. Sia never toured.
All the main pop girls have huge fanbases. Sia has a very small fanbase or just non-existent.
So to be a main pop girl you need to have an active base on ATRL?
Congrats to Katy having an active base on ATRL.net and for writing songs for multiple artists who happen to have an active fan base in the Base section of ATRL.net
Yes, that plus the other criteria Starstruck listed is what ATRL generally considers the requirements to be a main pop girl. Take it up with the rest of ATRL if you have a problem with that (although since it doesn't involve Katy you probably won't care!). Thanks for the praise for Katy though booboo!
The monsters trying their hardest to change the criteria to include Gaga but I'm still not seeing any main pop girl that wrote for multiple main pop girls like Katy! We've established Sia isn't a main pop girl yet, and Gaga has only written for Britney out of the main pop girls (writing for a remix where you sing the parts you wrote doesn't count as writing for someone else). Any questions?
Many pop artists "co-write", that doesn't mean they did any more than pitch in a few words/suggestions
We've learned this lesson enough times when demos of the original artist leaked
Too bad Katy doesn't belong to this 'category' when her songwriting has been praised by Sia herself and 3 of her main producers . Katy co-wrote 'Passenger', the song didnt make the cut for PRISM.
Still not seeing any main pop girl that wrote for multiple main pop girls like Katy! We've established Sia isn't a main pop girl yet, and Gaga has only written for Britney out of the main pop girls (writing for a remix where you sing the parts you wrote doesn't count as writing for someone else). Any questions?
We haven't established anything. You're making up your own rules here and embarrassing the Kats. I mean, I love Katy, but get a life. Thank you.
Literally no one said that or implied it. Now reply to my post and prove me wrong. xoxo
Prove you wrong? You just proved me right
I said from the beginning that the OP has specific qualifications of what a main pop girl is and he is specifically trying to push out all of the competition with all of the hoops you have to jump through just to find a damn artist that fits. It has so many qualifications, actually those qualifications are ...
Quote:
Originally posted by Starstruck.
All the main pop girls have 5M+ selling albums worldwide. Sia has none.
All the main pop girls have multiple Top 10 hits in the US and worldwide. Sia has one hit.
All the main pop girls have multiple AMAs, VMAs, EMAs, BRITs, etc. Sia has one VMA.
All the main pop girl have multiple platinum selling albums in the US. Sia doesn't even have a gold albums.
All the main pop girls have had cultural impact and are important figures in the media.
All the main pop girls are huge on social media. Sia isn't.
All the main pop girls have successful +100M tours or just successful tours. Sia never toured.
All the main pop girls have huge fanbases. Sia has a very small fanbase or just non-existent.
n.
so congrats to Katy for meeting all of those requirements and writing for another person who also meets those same requirements (and having an active fan base in the base section of atrl.net). Truly an achievement for the record books
Should fix that OP up to so its not so deceptive 
). JLO, TLC, Britney & Beyonce have sold 100s of millions of records/albums combined. More than Selena & Iggy at least (Katys girls). So yeah /end thread
. Katy co-wrote 'Passenger', the song didnt make the cut for PRISM.