[GetYourAssInMyBed]

Originally posted by ahauntingnearu

katy perry's TD album was never discounted nearly as low as gaga's BTW. case closed.

if you check BTW's first week sales in the US WITHOUT the amazon discount, it still did a lot more than PRISM is expected to do

[Squall]

Originally posted by GetYourAssInMyBed

if you check BTW's first week sales in the US WITHOUT the amazon discount, it still did a lot more than PRISM is expected to do

Who the hell cares?
Katy is able to have longevity, she did not get the half of her US total in a single week.

[SilencePlease]

Originally posted by ahauntingnearu

katy perry's TD album was never discounted nearly as low as gaga's BTW. case closed.

I like you

[Benzene]

Have we had the conversation about how percentages only reflect the percentage of retailers that have reported and NOT the proportion of sales that we seem to have with every big release?

If not, consider it had.

[Befour]

Originally posted by Benzene

Have we had the conversation about how percentages only reflect the percentage of retailers that have reported and NOT the proportion of sales that we seem to have with every big release?

If not, consider it had.

Still doesn't change the fact she won't debut with over 300k despite the HUGE smash that Roar was according to the Kats

She just hasn't got the star power

[Travis Bickle]

[Benzene]

Originally posted by Sexy ****

Still doesn't change the fact she won't debut with over 300k despite the HUGE smash that Roar was according to the Kats

She just hasn't got the star power

That's what I'm saying, sometimes people assume that the 46% is proportionate to sales (which would mean she'd be on track to sell over 350k). I'm saying that's not the case.

However, I won't make any declarative statements on her sales quite yet. My summer prediction was 250-300k though.

[Almighty Gaga]

Will she hit 300k

[QueenBeé]

How many times do Monsters have to explain that BTW sold 600k+ without the Amazon discount?

It's literally explained every f*ckin' hour in different threads yet no one understands.

Katy will increase when holiday time comes.

[Pie-kun]

The whole Amazon thing is moot anyways, that was a discount placed by Amazon themselves. All losses on that were taken on by Amazon, the label and Gaga got the same amount of money from it as they would have if those albums had sold at normal retail price. It's not the same as a label discounting and taking in less in per-album revenue.

[staracademy1990]

Considering how terrible the album is, I doubt she will have longevity.

Dark Horse & This is How We Do are her only hopes for smashes tbh.

[ALΞX]

Originally posted by collin

Wait!!!! Only HALF is in and she's already done 185k? Dang. She could do well, well over 300k!

Percentage in = the % of retailers reported.. it has nothing to do with the amount of sales.

[calumc]

NOW IN: 68.46%


LW TW artist / album label power index
-- 1 KATY PERY CAPITOL 244,441
PRISM
2 2 MILEY CYRUS RCA 35,865
BANGERZ
5 3 DRAKE YM/CM/REPUBLIC 33,333
NOTHING WAS THE SAME
7 4 LORDE REPUBLIC 30,398
PURE HEROINE
1 5 PEARL JAM MONKEYWRENCH/REPUBLIC 29,054
LIGHTNING BOLT
13 6 LUKE BRYAN CAPITOL NASHVILLE 21,638
CRASH MY PARTY
-- 7 DJ KHALED CASH MONEY/REPUBLIC 20,692
SUFFERING FROM SUCCESS
-- 8 FIFTH HARMONY SYCO/EPIC 20,677
BETTER TOGETHER EP
11 9 JUSTIN TIMBERLAKE RCA 20,065
20/20 EXPERIENCE 2 OF 2
-- 10 AFI REPUBLIC 16,694

[ElectricFrancis]

[Thisisit]

Originally posted by ALΞX

Percentage in = the % of retailers reported.. it has nothing to do with the amount of sales.

But, surely just by statistics, the proportion of retailers reported corresponds roughly to the proportion of sales? Unless for some reason retailers that sell more copies are more inclined to report early or something.

[Flare]

She's going to crack 300k. Bookmark me

[QueenBeé]

I've got a feeling that she will open with 300k.

[shelven]

iTunes better not have submitted yet, because if Fifth Harmony is #8 with their biggest seller having already submitted...

[Swim]

Originally posted by QueenBeé

I've got a feeling that she will open with 300k.

Yep!

[Almighty Gaga]

Almost there Katheryn.

You can do it. You can do it.