[TheVoiceXtina]

Originally posted by Glam

This is such a lie and I don't even use Beyonce. But I hate when people lie about chart placements.

http://www.mediatraffic.de/

[Watch'N'Learn]

and what impact did telephone have? Phenomena?
What sorta reach...

[Indigo Blue]

"Telephone" would've done better commercially if Beyonce's fans actually bought her singles.

If Rihanna can score a #1 with Britney, then yeah...

Could you imagine the 1st week sales and radio airplay for a Rihanna/Katy duet!

[superben]

Yes, of course

This, though

Britney and Christina will topple both

[Aden]

Originally posted by Watch'N'Learn

Well Rihanna is the one who blocked telephone from #1 with Rude Boy.
So yes. Rihanna's WW impact + Katy Perrys local impact is testimony to that.

I thought Telephone peaked at #3 in the US, though?
Plus, I'm almost certain Telephone went #1 worldwide.

[ThePatrickk]

Yes it will sales wise, but the song won't be as good

[Aden]

Originally posted by Watch'N'Learn

and what impact did telephone have? Phenomena?
What sorta reach...

It had cultural impact

[Glam]

Originally posted by HausOfA-M

What's Beyoncé's biggest WW hit and how much has it sold?

"Crazy In Love" finished second in the 2003 year end chart.

http://www.mediatraffic.de/singles-2003.htm

[Andre]

Originally posted by Watch'N'Learn

and what impact did telephone have? Phenomena?
What sorta reach...

The telephone cultural impact

etc...

[HausOfA-M]

Originally posted by Glam

"Crazy In Love" finished second in the 2003 year end chart.

http://www.mediatraffic.de/singles-2003.htm

Mediatraffic isn't reliable for singles, and even there 'Telephone' ammassed more points.

[Tysen]

Originally posted by Andre

The telephone cultural impact

etc...

DAMN I guess!!

I love me some cute japanese girls though especially dressed as beyonce and gaga.

--
Anyways, I might be slightly interested in this collaboration if Calvin Harris is involved

[JakeHouser]

No.

[Glam]

Originally posted by HausOfA-M

Mediatraffic isn't reliable for singles, and even there 'Telephone' ammassed more points.

It did not.

8.Telephone - Lady GaGa feat. Beyoncé
Interscope - 5.739.000 points

2.Crazy In Love - Beyoncé feat. Jay-Z
Columbia - 5.818.000 points

If it's not reliable then why did the OP link me to Mediatraffic?

[JakeHouser]

Originally posted by givemethatpop

Maybe.

Or maybe their collaboration is the one getting eclipsed by the upcoming Britney / Gaga

YES!!!

[HausOfA-M]

Originally posted by Glam

It did not.

8.Telephone - Lady GaGa feat. Beyoncé
Interscope - 5.739.000 points

2.Crazy In Love - Beyoncé feat. Jay-Z
Columbia - 5.818.000 points

If it's not reliable then why did the OP link me to Mediatraffic?

'Telephone' has some points from 2009, too. The total is 5.9M+.

And I don't know why the OP links you to Mediatraffic. It is reliable if you want to have a mix of airplay and sales, but IFPI is the official source for WW sales.

[Glam]

Originally posted by HausOfA-M

'Telephone' has some points from 2009, too. The total is 5.9M+.

And I don't know why the OP links you to Mediatraffic. It is reliable if you want to have a mix of airplay and sales, but IFPI is the official source for WW sales.

What makes you think Crazy in Love didn't get some points in 2004?

[Katy V.!]

It will flop if it's a mindless pop dance song produced by Luke/Stargate/Harris.

[HausOfA-M]

Originally posted by Glam

What makes you think Crazy in Love didn't get some points in 2004?

The fact it left the chart in 2003.

[cheers09]

how can some of you say it wont have the cultural impact,awesome song,etc. when you havent even heard it? y'all are trying to be raven and it aint cute.

[rihannafan]

Rihanna did it alone with Rude boy(no shade). So Katy being a nice addition, i'll vote yes.