You're moving the goal posts. You asked for a song; there it is. Now how about finding a song your own fave wrote on her own since lyricism seems to be so ~important to you, AALIYAH DANA.
Those are producers. Plus if you knew the back story behind that song, you wouldn't have post that mess. I bet you think independent woman part 1 was the original song.lol
Probably not a ton, but it's not a big deal since she pulls it all off with the conviction like she did write it. Songs were probably brought to her and she made some changes/catered them to her liking.
What's the point of this? Barbra Streisand wrote 0% of her AOTY winning album. It doesn't mean she or anyone else who doesn't write doesn't deserve it.
And all Beyoncé's collaborators say she is highly involved. The way it seems to work is she either receives songs, tells people how to change them, or changes them herself or works with people from the ground up to create the song as a collaborative effort. There's nothing wrong with that.
You're moving the goal posts. You asked for a song; there it is. Now how about finding a song your own fave wrote on her own since lyricism seems to be so ~important to you, AALIYAH DANA.
Welp! Well according to her logic, her fave is the new Diane Warren and Baby face.l
Yet she as her own different vocal production to the song
OK. That's like saying when someone does a cover of a song they should get writing credits for different "vocal production". It's completely absurd. They didn't write the song.
What's the point of this? Barbra Streisand wrote 0% of her AOTY winning album. It doesn't mean she or anyone else who doesn't write doesn't deserve it.
And all Beyoncé's collaborators say she is highly involved. The way it seems to work is she either receives songs, tells people how to change them, or changes them herself or works with people from the ground up to create the song as a collaborative effort. There's nothing wrong with that.
so would you put beyonce in the same category as songwriters like adele, taylor or mariah carey?
Yet she as her own different vocal production to the song
She has different runs and riffs on her track which he doesn't have
Again credits are more than just a pen and paper
She didn't change the composition though There are countless covers people have recorded, giving the song a complete facelift, but they didn't give themselves a writing credit. "Runs and riffs" aren't changing the composition.
That's literally proof of the messiness of it.