I'm still shocked, I thought this was a lock for Top 5 easily. What is there to really say about this? It's one of Kelly's most iconic songs. You can tell this was an Xtina reject from Stripped, but I can't imagine anyone but Kelly selling this song. The perfect lead single for her, it really established who she was as an artist and set the course for her future music. And Nightingale agrees, "This anthem still slays me over 13 years later. Kween creating classics."
This is the only song to receive more than one 11. My favorite track on the album, and a great album opener. Just wonderfully sung by Carrie, and well-written as well. Because Vilppu's rate is on my mind, this song reminds me a lot of Reba for some reason. It might be the storytelling in the middle of the song. Definitely her best album track, and worthy to be her #2.
Nightingale gushes, "Perfect country song. I love the story it tells. I can't believe I slept on this for so long." I agree with all of this.
Lyrically, this might be one of Kelly's best. I can't think of much to say, but there's a lot of depth to this song. Ryanicorn brings up a good point that I agree with 100%, "I prefer the version that's at the end of Breakaway, but this version isn't as bad as Belly tried to make it seem. " Nightingale also agrees, "This version is so underrated. The live version is good but I think I like this one better still." I find the production is very complementary to Kelly's performance, it doesn't drown her or the message out at all. I appreciate that this version of the song exists.
Is this Top 3 Worthy? I'm not sure, but I do think I agree with it's Top 10 placement and it being the highest coronation song. It's just so triumphant, and Kelly sounds so strong and vibrant. Her winning performance might be my favorite one, she's really adorable and she still kills it while in tears. It's very emotional, and very fitting for American Idol's first winner and star.
SO! Before He Cheats VS. Just Missed The Train. Who is our winner?!