[Swag]

Thank you tyler, even with the speed and the awful taste of members

[Lifeline]

[Petty Bourgeoisie]

Tyler, you were a wonderful, helpful, humorous host! You should do this again!

[Sanctuary]

Can we respect the fact that the OP was made on 9/08 and the rate is over on 10/30 though? I feel like rates usually take forever, or maybe just the rates I've participated in.

Tyler, ha time management skills

[Pandora]

I'll be back in 24hrs bc I'm banned due to the Halloween event. Thank you Tyler for this amazing rate, I love you and cherish you. Even tho Mer Girl didn't win.

Au revoir hunties and happy halloween

[Pandora]

Singles rate pls luv u x

[Sanctuary]

The worst thing about Mer Girl not winning is now we can't make a M.E.R. Girl pun in the title.

[Reverie]

Yeah I didn't appreciate AL and a lot of her later tracks at all before this thank you Tyler

[That Bad Eartha]

Thanks to everyone who participated!. This was my first rate ever and I could not be happier with how it turned out. Plus it helped turn me into a more active ATRL member and helped me feel like a part of the Madonna base.

Here is the spreadsheet with everyone's scores

And here is the album averages chart!

1. Bedtime Stories AVE: 7.491 High: 4. Love Tried to Welcome Me Low: 111. Let Down Your Guard	2. Ray of Light AVE: 7.435 High: 1. Sky Fits Heaven Low: 131. Gone Gone Gone	3. Like A Prayer AVE: 7.128 High: 13. Till Death Do Us Part Low: 113. Love Song	4. Erotica AVE: 7.041 High: 2. Thief of Hearts Low: 156. Queen's English
5. Music AVE: 7.018 High: 16. Impressive Instant Low: 132. Cyberraga	6. Confessions on a Dance Floor AVE: 7.016 High: 7. Forbidden Love Low: 167. Keep the Trance	7. American Life AVE: 6.917 High: 21. Easy Ride Low: 140. I'm So Stupid	8. Extras AVE: 6.376 High: I Want You Low: I'm In Love With Love
9. Rebel Heart AVE: 6.324 High: 9. Devil Pray Low: 175. Autotune Baby	10. MDNA AVE: 6.241 High: 24. Love Spent Low: 177. B-Day Song	11. Hard Candy AVE: 6.214 28. Devil Wouldn't Recognize You 172. Spanish Lesson	12. Like A Virgin AVE: 6.027 65. Stay 161. Shoo-Bee-Doo
13. I'm Breathless AVE: 5.761 86. Something to Remember 171. I'm Going Bananas	14. Madonna AVE: 5.588 High: 67. Physical Attraction/Think of Me Low: 165. Don't You Know	[B]15. True BlueB] AVE: 5.508 High: 68. White Heat Low: 174. Jimmy Jimmy

Here it is without the unreleased songs, not easily accessible bonus tracks, and b-sides (all of which were added to Extras average):
1. Bedtime Stories - 7.836293436
2. Ray of Light - 7.831081081
3. Confessions - 7.660810811
4. Erotica - 7.631756757
5. Music - 7.54528406
6. American Life - 7.3
7. Like A Prayer - 7.291891892
8. Rebel Heart - 7.256418919
9. Madonna - 6.642342342
10. Hard Candy - 6.462762763
11. MDNA - 6.241216216
12. Like A Virgin - 6.027027027
13. Extras - 5.9541271
14. I’m Breathless - 5.761389961
15. True Blue - 5.591216216

[Petty Bourgeoisie]

Originally posted by Pandora

Singles rate pls luv u x

Tbh

[Sanctuary]

Originally posted by tylerlscwv

AVE: 6.241
High: 24. Love Spent
Low: 177. B-Day Song

I see you trying to throw some last minute AL shade.

[Alongoria13]

I had a lot of fun, despite the fact my 11 left a month ago

Good job, Tyler!

[Reverie]

My ten 10s were to Waiting and White Heat, my 11 was to Til Death Do Us Apart. That's all!

[Subomie]

yas everyone go rally Ace to let us redo the singles rate I have a lot to say on the one.

[Reverie]

Lemme go bop to the entirety of 80s Madonna cuz this rate had me FEENIN for her

[Lifeline]

See y'all at Rebel Heart Torture!

Next week is my turn

[Reinvention]

Originally posted by C/H/A/N/E/L

We can collectively agree to ban Reinvention from further rates, though, correct?

Originally posted by Subomie

Reinvention never wins.

*bops to Incredible*

Originally posted by Reverie

Rebels (2): Reinvention
Rebels (3.4): Reinvention

The finishing touch.

Originally posted by THEBEASTWITHIN

And Reinvention finishes this flawlessly as usual, with a 2 for SFH AND a 3. 4 to TOH I truly can't at ya sis, I'm sorry
I know taste is subjective and I'm a HC lover but I do wish some say you get to appreciate the magic of Madonna's music. I mean, as a whole you know?
It's not understandable to rank the amount of terrific songs with a 1 or 2 like you did
I don't mean to be rude, sorry, but sometimes I do wonder if you were just trolling....

Anyway, a good winner, coming from one of ha best albums.

Congratulations Tyler! You were a FANTASTIC host and gave us all a great time. This was eventful like the good sis Buyonce said
A big hand to you

I feel like Erotica-era Madonna trying to show her face in the Southern states.

I'm sorry ya'll hate my taste.

Thanks Tyler for an incredibly entertaining rate! It's honestly been my favourite thing over the past two weeks, loved it. But not so much being the leper of the base.

[That Bad Eartha]

Originally posted by Subomie

yas everyone go rally Ace to let us redo the singles rate I have a lot to say on the one.

We really need to do either a singles or discography rate again (I looked at the discography one that had been done before opening this and talk about a tragedy. Like bad results, and a terrible host). Because all that is left to do officially is a videography rate. I hate that you can only do these things once. Worst comes to worse we can always do an unofficial one in the bases.

I think Quicksand is hosting the Rebel Heart vs Unbreakable vs Kiss Me Once vs Me I Am Mariah, so we have that to look forward to.





And thanks to everyone complimenting me. I really appreciate them all and I'm glad you all enjoyed the rate and got into some more of the Queen's discography (tbh there were some songs I had never listened to before this rate even)

[Subomie]

Originally posted by Reinvention

I feel like Erotica-era Madonna trying to show her face in the Southern states.

even though you'll give my 11 another 0 you have to do the next rate

[That Bad Eartha]

Originally posted by Reinvention

I feel like Erotica-era Madonna trying to show her face in the Southern states.

I'm sorry ya'll hate my taste.

Thanks Tyler for an incredibly entertaining rate! It's honestly been my favourite thing over the past two weeks, loved it. But not so much being the leper of the base.

Thanks Reinvention. I still hate your taste and might never forgive you for knocking Till Death Do Us Part out of the top 10, but you have been an important this too. Everyone needs someone to drag in a rate. That just ended up being you in the end. You helped give some good kiis. And it isn't like you are some annoying troll member who secretly hates Madonna and just sabotaged the rate. You just have very questionable opinions.