Member Since: 6/15/2012
Posts: 5,059
|
And the winner is....
1. Sky Fits Heaven
Average - 8.703
Album: Ray of Light
Rank within album: 1st of 14
Hearts (11): Eeveelution, Humoresque (10): tylerlscwv, conatus, GarageGlamorous, enxe, JakeKills, Quicksand, eli’s_rhythm, Superiore, HausOfCarlos, Brunette Ambition, Meowster, Dark Miracles, Kyle-x, C/H/A/N/E/L, Alongoria13, dabunique, XStaticProcess, SupremeGoddess
Rebels (2): Reinvention
Host commentary - A fitting winner. It is a glorious dance track, yet also a left of field song. It really encapsulates what makes Madonna so special.
Guest commentary
Eeveelution’s commentary- It's weird because I can't really think of anything to say about it despite it being my 11, other than it's a flawless masterpiece and should obvs win. xoxo
Subomie - The chorus melody is beautiful but some of the lyrics... Still would've been a better single choice than Nothing Really Matters.
Pandora – Not my top pick from the album but it’s alright.
Alongoria13 - Listen to it at the beach when it's cold and thank me later.
And the runner up:
2. Thief of Hearts
Average - 8.573
Album: Erotica
Rank within album: 1st of 13
Hearts (10): tylerlscwv, Quicksand, Shaliydah88, Eeveelution, Subomie, HausOfCarlos, Pandora, C/H/A/N/E/L, mrmikefern, dabunique, XStaticProcess, SupremeGoddess
Rebels (3.4): Reinvention
Host commentary - An amazing bop and such an empowering and bitchy track.
Guest commentary
Pandora - *glass smashes* Bitch! - flawless, feisty, gay anthem.
Lifeline - A milestone in M's recording career. Don't forget, M name dropped this masterpiece in 2015! Let's quote the incident of #AskMadonnaOnInstagram at this occasion: "Thief of hearts is too submersive, it would never get played on the radio" Madonna said. So was 'Living For Love' submersive too? The fact that it's still too submersive (mess, lemme look it up) for one of her tours until this day though.
Reinvention - Show’s promise, but her voice just sound weirdly empty – like she’s singing but she doesn’t care?
Eeveelution - I just love how bitchy this is! Added some much needed life to the album.
Subomie- Dramatic and dynamic! Never a dull moment as it constantly shifts and changes and keeps you hooked. A diamond in the rough of this album.
mrmikefern - Ugh Gangdonna >>>
Alongoria13 - One of Madonna's best album tracks; danceable, shady and gay.
Pandora – I genuinely think this is one of the most iconic gems from her discography (for the gays, at least), and it has every reason to be!
|
|
|
|
And thanks Tyler for hosting! 
Reinvention never wins.