[***Chu]

Whitney, duh.

[Mimie]

This thread again

[Duca]

Whitney.

[ABEL-o-matic]

Originally posted by Rolland

If Whitney's only iconic moment is the Bodyguard momentum then Mariah doesn't even have something iconic at all...

How ignorant.

If Whitney was the greatest vocalists of all time, then how come there are hundreds of girls who can give justice to her songs and sing them just as good - if not, better than her?

What about Mariah's songs? No one dares to sing Mariah songs because it's impossible to do so.

Whitney's head voice is abysmal, her vocal range is only 3 octaves, she goes really thin after E5, he low notes are unsupported. Her chest voice is just loud, that's about it.

[Rolland]

Originally posted by ABEL-o-matic

If Whitney was the greatest vocalists of all time, then how come there are hundreds of girls who can give justice to her songs and sing them just as good - if not, better than her?

What about Mariah's songs? No one dares to sing Mariah songs because it's impossible to do so.

Whitney's head voice is abysmal, her vocal range is only 3 octaves, she goes really thin after E5, he low notes are unsupported. Her chest voice is just loud, that's about it.

Chimier, do your thing please.

People CAN sing Mariah's song. The only "difficult" part could be the whistles. But let's not act like they are something impossible to do.

You're clearly a deluded stan and that's ok. To each their own.

[fpppy]

Whitney Houston

[ABEL-o-matic]

Originally posted by Rolland

Chimier, do your thing please.

People CAN sing Mariah's song. The only "difficult" part could be the whistles. But let's not act like they are something impossible to do.

You're clearly a deluded stan and that's ok. To each their own.

That's the thing. People who have the whistles don't have the chest voice to support her F5-G5s. People who can nail the high belts don't have the range after E6.

Whitney's songs are easier to sing because all they need is a loud, booming chest voice. Hell, even Nicole Scherzinger can nail I Will Always Love You.

[Cherry Noir]

Mim vs Nippy



Refer back to the 10,000 other polls like this. Search bar is your friend.

[Rolland]

Originally posted by ABEL-o-matic

That's the thing. People who have the whistles don't have the chest voice to support her F5-G5s. People who can nail the high belts don't have the range after E6.

Whitney's songs are easier to sing because all they need is a loud, booming chest voice. Hell, even Nicole Scherzinger can nail I Will Always Love You.

At you diminishing Whitney like that.

Whistling is not even a thing anymore. It never was actually. Mariah was technically flawless, yet to be a vocalist involves more than hitting the notes perfectly for me. That must be the difference between me and you.

Whitney on the other hand had everything. She was perfect, she had it all. She knew how to move you with her singing and that's way more important than a well-supported F5 or an breathy G6.

Anyway, I respect your opinion, that's it. Move on!

[EJQL8]

I think they're pretty much equal. I'll vote for Mariah though, because she's involved in her career, while Whitney is pretty much a label puppet.

[ABEL-o-matic]

Originally posted by Rolland

At you diminishing Whitney like that.

Whistling is not even a thing anymore. It never was actually. Mariah was technically flawless, yet to be a vocalist involves more than hitting the notes perfectly for me. That must be the difference between me and you.

Whitney on the other hand had everything. She was perfect, she had it all. She knew how to move you with her singing and that's way more important than a well-supported F5 or an breathy G6.

Anyway, I respect your opinion, that's it. Move on!

But what about her sales after the Bodyguard Soundtrack? Her her last concert? Mariah can't sell stadiums well, but she at least kept her voice somewhat still decent.

Originally posted by EJQL8

I think they're pretty much equal. I'll vote for Mariah though, because she's involved in her career, while Whitney is pretty much a label puppet.

Thank you.

[skyler]

Originally posted by EJQL8

I think they're pretty much equal. I'll vote for Mariah though, because she's involved in her career, while Whitney is pretty much a label puppet.

nothing but the truth

[fortheloveofmusic]

Originally posted by ABEL-o-matic

If Whitney was the greatest vocalists of all time, then how come there are hundreds of girls who can give justice to her songs and sing them just as good - if not, better than her?

What about Mariah's songs? No one dares to sing Mariah songs because it's impossible to do so.

Whitney's head voice is abysmal, her vocal range is only 3 octaves, she goes really thin after E5, he low notes are unsupported. Her chest voice is just loud, that's about it.

That's when I knew that you were full of delusion.

[atrlster]

Calling Whitney a puppet seems like its a bit much..

[Pecinta Mariah]

IT's pretty hard you know to vote between them, they are labelled as The Voice
both have influence and iconic songs
but I have to pick Mariah since she popularized melisma and introducing pop/rap collabo

[ABEL-o-matic]

Originally posted by fortheloveofmusic

That's when I knew that you were full of delusion.

Her transition to head voice is bad. She breaks when she goes to her head voice.

[skyler]

Originally posted by atrlster

Calling Whitney a puppet seems like its a bit much..

she was one career was controlled by clive davis

[fortheloveofmusic]

Idk why some Mariah stans can't accept that they BOTH have had an immense impact on music, Pop culture, and artists. There's no need to try to diminish Whitney to make Mariah look better, and vise-versa.

Whitney influenced or inspired almost every singer that came after her, INCLUDING Mariah and Celine.

Originally posted by ABEL-o-matic

Her transition to head voice is bad. She breaks when she goes to her head voice.

That's a bold-faced lie. If anything she had the best seamless transitions from head voice to chest voice.

[ABEL-o-matic]

Originally posted by Pecinta Mariah

IT's pretty hard you know to vote between them, they are labelled as The Voice
both have influence and iconic songs
but I have to pick Mariah since she popularized melisma and introducing pop/rap collabo

Mariah took risks in her career. I mean If it wasn't for Daydream, we wouldn't have the popstars that we have today.

[annashaus]

I think we all know the answer to THAT.