[danxc33]

This poll ended being just Demi vs Ariana as I though, but Katy>>>Rihanna

Firework is x10 harder than any Riri song and if it wasn't for her lack of Breath support she could be considered better than Ariana too





And any of the songs performed here

[Timber]

Originally posted by DemiNem

Yes it is technical. Power, range, control, it's all technical. Which is why Mariah is considered the best vocalist of all time if not second best.

And belting is what makes you a vocalist instead of a singer. It's really the most important part of singing.

Demi - has a more versatile voice, more original sound, much more power & strength to her voice, arguably better high notes (even though more restricted than Ariana) better at belting, and conveys emotions better

Ariana - has a bigger range, has a more agile voice and is better at controlling her voice

I think she also has less pitch problems. (Btw producing correct pitches is more important than being able to belt. Whitney Houston didn't even know how to belt at all)

[Grown K]

Originally posted by SuccesLovato

Your opinion! IMO Ariana's vocals are overrated, I mean she's good but she only holds a great technique cause I don't think she emotes very well.
The poll results happen to be caught in the hype of her album.

She cried while singing one of her songs. I don't know how much deeper can she emote...

4:07

[DemiNem]

Originally posted by danxc33

This poll ended being just Demi vs Ariana as I though, but Katy>>>Rihanna

Firework is x10 harder than any Riri song and if it wasn't for her lack of Breath support she could be considered better than Ariana too





And any of the songs performed here

I think she has natural talent but needs a lot of training. Smh wasted talent :/

[Timber]

Rihanna > Katy. Although Katy shows more technical prowess, she loses major points for being so pitchy.

[DemiNem]

Originally posted by Timber

I think she also has less pitch problems. (Btw producing correct pitches is more important than being able to belt. Whitney Houston didn't even know how to belt at all)

Whitney is the Queen of belts. Power + vibrato.

And yes I agree, but Demi does know how to correct pitches. She just gets sick A LOT (tonsils).

And her recent performances have been a bit pithy because she has to recover from her throat surgery.

But when she hits it.........

Both are important though. Holding a note is what usually solidifies them as a vocalist

[GeminiGurl09]

Demi and Ariana Obviously lol.

[DemiNem]

Originally posted by Grown K

She cried while singing one of her songs. I don't know how much deeper can she emote...

4:07

[prunejuicemontes]

Not Rihanna.

[SuccesLovato]

Originally posted by Grown K

She cried while singing one of her songs. I don't know how much deeper can she emote...

4:07

Being able to emote doesn't mean crying while performing, it's basically showcasing powerful vocals through emotions (moods, feelings) that's why Demi sounds completely different in each genre... She can do pop, rock, r&b, EDM, ballads... She can do whatever and that's what Ariana lacks on, for instance I don't see Ariana pulling a "Heart by heart" tbh

[AnotherGagaFan]

Originally posted by jomarr

Ariana>Katy>>>>Rihanna>>>Demi

What a joke

[Grown K]

Originally posted by SuccesLovato

Being able to emote doesn't mean crying while performing, it's basically showcasing powerful vocals through emotions (moods, feelings) that's why Demi sounds completely different in each genre... She can do pop, rock, r&b, EDM, ballads... She can do whatever and that's what Ariana lacks on, for instance I don't see Ariana pulling a "Heart by heart" tbh

I just don't like Demi's voice/technique, it sounds so tense and uncontrolled. Ariana is better in my opinion, but you prefer Demi and that's life

[SuccesLovato]

Originally posted by Grown K

I just don't like Demi's voice/technique, it sounds so tense and uncontrolled. Ariana is better in my opinion, but you prefer Demi and that's life

Fair enough!

[Lord Gaga]

Ariana>Demi>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> ... Rihanna and katy

[Cherry]

Demi is the best vocally. Ariana may be able to do more but her voice isn't distinctive which is why people mistake her for Mariah Carey.

[AnotherGagaFan]

Corny ass **** people pull with the "emotion" crap.

Whitney Houston was too much of an airhead to feel anything live, and she was cracked out, did that make her less of a vocalist?

Kurt Cobain was more emotional than any of the pop girls, but nobody compares him to Mariah or Celine. Like shutup.

[SuccesLovato]

Originally posted by Cherry

Demi is the best vocally. Ariana may be able to do more but her voice isn't distinctive which is why people mistake her for Mariah Carey.

Good point. The distinctiveness of the voice!

[BrittRihanna134]

Ariana
Demi
Rihanna
Katy

[DemiNem]

Originally posted by AnotherGagaFan

Corny ass **** people pull with the "emotion" crap.

Whitney Houston was too much of an airhead to feel anything live, and she was cracked out, did that make her less of a vocalist?

Kurt Cobain was more emotional than any of the pop girls, but nobody compares him to Mariah or Celine. Like shutup.

WHAT IS THIS MESS LMFAO

Any music fan would know that emotion and passion is the most important part of being a singer

Edit: Even though there's a lot of technical stuff to go a long with vocals, singing isn't a science, it's an art. Passion or ability to convey emotions>technique ANY day.

[Cyanide]

Originally posted by Timber

1) Ariana
2) Demi
3) Rihanna
4) Katy

This