[Witness]

Erika better get in. I don't know why they made her go second, she has one of the best voices in the group easily.

[fortheloveofmusic]

I forgot about the Wild Card thing can some1 explain it to me please lol

[Quiqui4eva]

Originally posted by Sept

i just can't @ all the girls got praised while only Haley was criticized
Do they have a thing against "Haley" girl

You really think Haley was better than Jessica?

[Sept]

Elise is amazing

Final ranking

1. Elise
2. Skylar
3. Jessica
4. Erika
5. Hollie - she's too basic for me though
6. Shannon
7. Hallie
8. Jen
9. Haley
10. Chelsea
11. Brielle
12. Baylie

[Sept]

hopefully Haley will get through by her beauty and her "not generic" song choice

[biomind101]

Hollie Cavanagh was breathtaking!!!

[Parks]

Originally posted by Sept

hopefully Haley will get through by her beauty and her "not generic" song choice

She was the worst of the night though. I cannot see her going through even though I know she's better than what she showed us tonight.

1. Jessica
2. Skylar
3. Elise
4. Jen
5. Holly

TBH though everyone aside from Jessica and Skylar has done much better. Elise was pretty good but I know she's better, same for Jen, and although Holly's voice was good the song choice weighed her down.

[Sept]

She was the worst of the night though. I cannot see her going through even though I know she's better than what she showed us tonight.

never say never




















































My favs girls are always eliminated on the first night through Haley Reinhart is an exception

[Sept]

YAS VFTW supports Haley, get that votes

[JakeHouser]

Oh my gosh... JESSICA SANCHEZ... She will win. I already called it last week. Dang.

[Shy Boy]

Guys! Tonight was such a complete turnaround from last night. I liked nearly every performance, the only person that flat out sucked was Baylie. It's so hard to just pick 5 girls but these are who I want to go through:

1. Jessica Sanchez
2. Hollie
3. Jen Hirsh
4. Elise Testone
5. Brielle Von Hugel ---> Totally surprised me, she gave me Haley Reinhart moments

Wildcard:
6. Shannon
7. Haley Johnson---> she had an off night but I really see a mini Florence Welch in her

[Shy Boy]

Originally posted by Superbitch

UGH probably not I enjoy diversity/different races but American idol always has white girls Only reason i like the XF better

I hadn't noticed that Jessica was the only minority among the girls until my mom pointed out that nearly every girl was blonde.

[Shy Boy]

Originally posted by jpsketch

Lawd, this Shannon girl is rich.

I swear they all are. If I was on the show I would be embarrassed to film my little ole house.

[Benzene]

I missed the whole last half of the show. Visitors.

But I'm rooting for Hallie.

[Shy Boy]

Originally posted by fortheloveofmusic

I forgot about the Wild Card thing can some1 explain it to me please lol

The top 5 guys and the top 5 girls automatically make it to the finals. Then the judges will pick 6 contestants to sing again, of those 6 the judges will pick 3 to move on to the finals, rounding out the top 13.

Originally posted by Benzene

I missed the whole last half of the show. Visitors.

But I'm rooting for Hallie.

You can watch the other performances here. Make sure you watch Jessica's

[Mezik]

Chelsea did horrible covering Carrie.
Have these contestants not learned from past seasons & Glee that you cannot cover Carrie songs.

[zzzzzzy]

I'm only halfway though the episode, but the girls have definitely restored my faith in this season.

[FAN]

How many go home tomorrow? 5? I say Chelsea, Erika, Jen, Baylie & Haley.

Highlights: Brielle, Skylar, Hollie

[tj hazuki]

Top 2:
Elise Testone & Jessica Sanchez
no order <3

[Sept]

Originally posted by FAN

How many go home tomorrow? 5? I say Chelsea, Erika, Jen, Baylie & Haley.

Highlights: Brielle, Skylar, Hollie

5 will advance through by fan votes
and i believe 2 or even 3 girls will get the wildcard