[FreeBitch]

Originally posted by ManDown

You're here for Erotica? That's the one Madonna album I could never get into besides the singles. It's unfortunate. Maybe it's because I've always preferred Bedtime Stories. I need to give it a second listen.

And why aren't more Ray Of Light stans here for this?

Yes i'm probably on the minority but Erotica is a MASTERPIECE. I love Bedtimes Stories but it has too many fillers

[RatedG²]

Originally posted by ManDown

That's the one song on Confessions I never liked. But I'm biased because I loved the original FL.

I love both, but Confessions makes the song danceable. Well they aren't the same to begin with, but it sounds much better on Confessions imo

[Sahn]

Originally posted by Ace Reject

(the best song about her mother she's ever made. Deal.)

Probably.

But Mer Girl is far more deep and experimental. I flinch to it.

[eli's_rhythm]

Originally posted by RatedG²

fdsjfoibjr

I'm still convinced i'm straight

You're in a Madonna's best song thread.

[RatedG²]

Originally posted by eli's_rhythm

You're in a Madonna's best song thread.

[elliotis19]

Basically all of this:

[@michael]

We should do something where everyone submits their Top 20 songs (20 points for #1, 1 point for #20) and then tally the votes and see what the Top 50 or whatever is. Similar to an album rate, but Madge has too many albums to do this.

[RatedG²]

Take A Bow *****...end of

Goodnight

[£100]

Ok, so Get Together is definitely overrated to the high heavens. It's a great track but let's not wax hyperbolic.

Meanwhile, Into the Groove is the ultimate I'm-gonna-roll-down-the-car-windows-and-blast-me-some-Madonna track. FACT.

[FreeBitch]

Seriously i still dont understand how Madonna did to sells so much copies of Bed Times Stories. There are too many fillers and the Great American Life flop .

[ManDown]

Originally posted by FreeBitch

Yes i'm probably on the minority but Erotica is a MASTERPIECE. I love Bedtimes Stories but it has too many fillers

I was never able to fully appreciate it. I need to give it a second chance.

Originally posted by RatedG²

I love both, but Confessions makes the song danceable. Well they aren't the same to begin with, but it sounds much better on Confessions imo

True, it takes the song to a different level. But the original song's lyrics are amazing.

Originally posted by @michael.

We should do something where everyone submits their Top 20 songs (20 points for #1, 1 point for #20) and then tally the votes and see what the Top 50 or whatever is. Similar to an album rate, but Madge has too many albums to do this.

I was just thinking this the last time we had one of these "best song by Madonna" threads! Somebody needs to do it.

[@michael]

Originally posted by £100

Ok, so Get Together is definitely overrated to the high heavens. It's a great track but let's not wax hyperbolic.

Meanwhile, Into the Groove is the ultimate I'm-gonna-roll-down-the-car-windows-and-blast-me-some-Madonna track. FACT.

Into the Groove is the ugly step-sister of Holiday, IMO

[Ace Reject]

Originally posted by ManDown

I was never able to fully appreciate it. I need to give it a second chance.



True, it takes the song to a different level. But the original song's lyrics are amazing.



I was just thinking this the last time we had one of these "best song by Madonna" threads! Somebody needs to do it.

That would be me. But let the idea marinate - it coincides with an idea I ALREADY HAVE Man Down and @michael.

And all this RoL talk and no love for Sky Fits Heaven? For shame.

[£100]

Originally posted by @michael.

Into the Groove is the ugly step-sister of Holiday, IMO

And yet Holiday will simply not do when you're at the intersection waiting for the light to change.

[Lipton]

Originally posted by £100

Meanwhile, Into the Groove is the ultimate I'm-gonna-roll-down-the-car-windows-and-blast-me-some-Madonna track. FACT.

No lie there. I've done it before.

But I thought we were going to discuss that epic laugh in the middle of Die Another Day.

[elliotis19]

Originally posted by RatedG²

Take A Bow *****...end of

Goodnight

Yup.

[ManDown]

Originally posted by Ace Reject

That would be me. But let the idea marinate - it coincides with an idea I ALREADY HAVE Man Down and @michael.

And all this RoL talk and no love for Sky Fits Heaven? For shame.

Okay. I can't wait to see what you have in store. It'll settle the debate once and for all.

"Sky Fits Heaven" is my 5th favorite on Ray Of Light.

[elliotis19]

Originally posted by £100

Ok, so Get Together is definitely overrated to the high heavens. It's a great track but let's not wax hyperbolic.

Meanwhile, Into the Groove is the ultimate I'm-gonna-roll-down-the-car-windows-and-blast-me-some-Madonna track. FACT.

"At night I lock the doors where no one else can see..."

[Lipton]

Originally posted by £100

And yet Holiday will simply not do when you're at the intersection waiting for the light to change.

Precisely. You are really coming hard tonight. I never play Holiday on the streets.

[ManDown]

You guys will not make me blast "Into The Groove" at 1AM.