[tj hazuki]

Originally posted by Foxaylove

Key word "winners", meaning the general public were here for them....

Yet the only one who had a million selling CD after the show was David Cook. And that was only one era.

[Superbitch]

Originally posted by Foxaylove

She's a REALLY REALLY REALLY smart chick, I mean she goes to University of Southern California. That's LEGIT right there! Cali is full of talented computer engineers and filmers, not that hard to find someone to help put together a video like she did. USC also has an amazing performing arts program, so I am sure there are connections and networking she took advantage of.

She really is. Here's hoping she'll get signed and stick it to Nicole la and.Paula. I can see this becoming an internet sensation Ala Friday.

[foxaylove]

Originally posted by hazuki

Yet the only one who had a million selling CD after the show was David Cook. And that was only one era.

Yet you don't see any of the others in their seasons doing better than them, with the exception of Adam Lambert.

[IWasHere]

Originally posted by Superbitch

I'm a Simone stan now. but how in the world she got a music video.like that? It looks even.better than some pop star's videos. Something's fishy. I think she had a deal already.

Simone is goin to get sign to a label, she has so so vocals but she also has the it factor.

[acive]

drew , intensity and leroy for the win!!!! great 1st live show!!!

[ifyouseekLEM]

Originally posted by Foxaylove

!!!!

After the performances today, I would've taken Phillip over Chris. The boy's voice cracked throughout his performance, though I know he was capable of way more. Chris Rene is over-hyped and has no star presence. He just has "swag" and that's it.

Miss Love spill the tea as usual.

[Vin]

It was kind of disappointing how Nicole Scherzinger and Paula weren't giving any of "the girls" any love. And Nicole should have been the last one to throw criticism, because all of her contestants are wack.

...Vin

[DG1]

Simone

[satellites.™]

Queen Battle is unbothered.

[Shy Boy]

Originally posted by Benzene

In retrospect I really think he should've kept Simone. Wtf is Rachel gonna do? Waste of a pick. It should've been Drew/Simone/Melanie.

Simone was one of my favorites but she would not get votes! People were already turned off by her because of the"bitch" edit she got during the auditions and bootcamp.

Originally posted by Foxaylove

I agree! Marcus has a huge upside and knows how to perform. LA will have to be careful how he trains Marcus if he wants the boy to win. I think we're looking at a top 3 right now of Stacy, Drew, and my dark horse...Astro (though he may be a reach). I am confident Stacy and Drew will be top 3 though!

Yeah, I would say Stacy and Drew are going to make the finals. If its a 4 person final then the other 2 could possibly be Melanie and maybe Marcus. That's a pretty solid finale. Astro will probably make the top 6/5.

I think the Overs are going to do very well, in comparison to how they do on the British show.

[Stepfon]

Originally posted by Vin

It was kind of disappointing how Nicole Scherzinger and Paula weren't giving any of "the girls" any love. And Nicole should have been the last one to throw criticism, because all of her contestants are wack.

...Vin

It's interesting that Nicole was given the people OVER 30 who are trying to still make it as a major popstar.

[acive]

Originally posted by Vin

It was kind of disappointing how Nicole Scherzinger and Paula weren't giving any of "the girls" any love. And Nicole should have been the last one to throw criticism, because all of her contestants are wack.

...Vin

Nicole did better this time IMO, she has leroy... reid was kinda strange today... and paula was really hard on the girls...

[Superbitch]

OK now Nicole stans.... I really want to hear what y'all have to say now.
Y'all were saying she was a terrible judge cuz it was taped and that she was going to get better on live shows. Mmm what the hell happened? She is terrible. No charisma and seems like does not have a clue of what's she doing. Simon seemed really uninterested on her tbh. She'll most likely be replaced soon. I expected critics to.go.hard on her again.

[tj hazuki]

Originally posted by Foxaylove

Yet you don't see any of the others in their seasons doing better than them, with the exception of Adam Lambert.

Better than who, exactly? Adam will flop next CD. It just the way it is with male Idol contestants.

[acive]

Originally posted by Stepfon

It's interesting that Nicole was given the people OVER 30 who are trying to still make it as a major popstar.

they had a random draw or something or maybe the producers where whack.... she would have done justice with Groups...

[foxaylove]

I actually agreed with the criticism Paula and Nicole gave some of the girls. Fact of the matter is, Simon popped off at the mouth throughout the whole show about every judge and how badly of song choices they picked for their crew, yet his group almost had the biggest bombing of all the judges (Paula had the biggest dud, but that's because the group category is the weakest of the four).

[acive]

Originally posted by Superbitch

OK now Nicole stans.... I really want to hear what y'all have to say now.
Y'all were saying she was a terrible judge cuz it was taped and that she was going to get better on live shows. Mmm what the hell happened? She is terrible. No charisma and seems like does not have a clue of what's she doing. Simon seemed really uninterested on her tbh. She'll most likely be replaced soon. I expected critics to.go.hard on her again.

she is being demure IMO softspoken, in the UK edition she was like a bit more relaxed and Fun , she is so uptight.... paula is again whack , reid was like kinda lost IMO

[Superbitch]

Originally posted by acive

they had a random draw or something or maybe the producers where whack.... she would have done justice with Groups...

You didn't get the shade

[foxaylove]

For me, LA Reid made the judging panel watchable and listenable tonight. The others were a hot mess today with the cattiness, granted LA was shading contestants from left to right for FILTH.

Simon really showed his ego tonight. He refused to admit that he bombed tonight, especially after Simone's performance. The only person from his group I was impressed with was Drew, the song and setting was perfect for her.

[acive]

Originally posted by Foxaylove

I actually agreed with the criticism Paula and Nicole gave some of the girls. Fact of the matter is, Simon popped off at the mouth throughout the whole show about every judge and how badly of song choices they picked for their crew, yet his group almost had the biggest bombing of all the judges (Paula had the biggest dud, but that's because the group category is the weakest of the four).

as usual simon wants to have a hold at everything, maybe its gets better if he'd mentor all contestants and make it the S Factor.