[Space]

that review

I would be interested to see what he considers a 5 star album.

[iforgiveyou]

Originally posted by Space

that review

I would be interested to see what he considers a 5 star album.

Well, if you look at the things he "likes" they include a rapper and a bundle of European acts. The guy needs to get pulled from the Independent and I think all Kelly stans need to send an email to the Independent to show their disgust for this hack job of a reviewer.

[stoopidjenna]

He rated James Morrison's newest album 1 star as well I love James Morrison. I haven't heard the album yet though (has it even been released in the states?)

[Mzd]

Originally posted by iforgiveyou

Well, if you look at the things he "likes" they include a rapper and a bundle of European acts. The guy needs to get pulled from the Independent and I think all Kelly stans need to send an email to the Independent to show their disgust for this hack job of a reviewer.

Another new stan


I looked for his email/twitter/facebook nothing

[iforgiveyou]

Don't email him. Email [email protected]. He is part of the feature section and have them review his reviews. I think they are going to find that this hack job has no business reviewing anything. If he was more impartial than leaving a total slam, it would be different.

[Mzd]

Originally posted by iforgiveyou

Don't email him. Email [email protected]. He is part of the feature section and have them review his reviews. I think they are going to find that this hack job has no business reviewing anything. If he was more impartial than leaving a total slam, it would be different.

So basically write a serious complant letter about Andy Gill and explain why he is not fitted to be rating albums

[iforgiveyou]

Yes. Don't be a stan in the email either. Reference other albums as well. The more collective proof there is, the bigger the toll will be. When you look at his reviews, they are silly fluff pieces.

[tell_me_a_lie]

Guys and bitches, don't deal with that reviewer..he's a waste of time and energy..lets move on and wait for the good things to happen with this album..

[Mzd]

My email:

I am starting to have a serious and major concern with a writer of yours, Andy Gill. I do not understand how he is in charge of doing album reviews with so little knowledge in the album or even giving a decent review on it. How is it fair to have a job that others would respect and do much more for and put more effort into it. Then, some biased joe, who seems to hate everything and anything that does not fit HIS specific needs. A professional review such as The Independent should also considered the public eye into its review or at least state that it could appeal to certain age categories.
It just blows my mind that someone would also actually still have someone with his nature and bad taste in music, do these reviews.

Thank you for taking the time to review this, and I hope to hear that some action will be taken place on this situation.

Sincerely,
Concerned Music Lover

[tell_me_a_lie]

Originally posted by Mzd

My email:

one flawless stan

[P!nk]

Originally posted by Mzd

My email:

You go gurl!

[Maybe]

Originally posted by Mzd

My email:

[Mzd]

Originally posted by tell_me_a_lie

one flawless stan

Originally posted by P!nk

You go gurl!

Originally posted by Maybe

Thanks

Now, I am cracking and going to listen to the full The Sun Will Rise, because my stupid order has not even been shipped yet, so I wont even get it till like the 25 or 26
Review once I finish it

[Maybe]

3 more days

[kellyc2005]

I find that with reviews (in general), for both music and movies, there is a great deal of bias and flawed opinions. if something is given a bad review, I sometimes wind up loving it. If it's given a good review, I might wind up hating it. So I pay little attention to reviews. What matters is that the fans like it, and Kelly has yet to disappoint me.

[Mzd]

1st 5 seconds so far remind me of the Titanic

[RihMark]

1. Mr Know It All - 8.6/10
2. Stronger - 10/10
3. Dark Side - 8.8/10
4. Honestly - 8.5/10
5. You Love Me - 8.6/10
6. Einstein - 9/10
7. Standing In Front Of You - 8.3/10
8. I Forgive You - 9/10
9. Hello - 9.8/10
10. The War Is Over - 9/10
11. Let Me Down - 9.7/10
12. You Cant Win - 9.6/10
13. Breaking Your Own Heart - 8.4/10
14. Dont You Wanna Stay - 8.1/10
15. Alone - 9/10
16. Dont Be A Girl About It - 9/10
17. The Sun Will Rise - 8.2/10
18. Why Dont You Try - 9.5/10

AVERAGE: 9.0

Excellent album.

[P!nk]

Originally posted by Mzd

Thanks

Now, I am cracking and going to listen to the full The Sun Will Rise, because my stupid order has not even been shipped yet so I wont even get it till like the 25 or 26
Review once I finish it

Seriously?! I wonder why... I also read that when you order the CD it says allow 8-18 days to be delivered once it's shipped

[Mzd]

Originally posted by P!nk

Seriously?! I wonder why... I also read that when you order the CD it says allow 8-18 days to be delivered once it's shipped

I am just going to hope that they were just so overwhelmed with so many pre orders they are having a hard time doing the 100-200 thousand orders

[KevinKDC]

I'm glad Why Don't You Try isn't on the album..... it kinda sucks lol. What a downgrade from the live version.