[Anthagio]

Originally posted by B3NK3V1N

http://atrl.net/forums/showthread.php?t=133052

It was Porcelain I think.

Anyways, I hope she keeps RedOne for one track at least. I think having only one track on an album will force him and Gaga to really create a masterpiece.

I think i'm just biased and pissed off at his "PB is the next LG" comments. xD

[Symphonic]

Originally posted by Anthagio

I don't think so, TBH. After the public fall out and RedOne claiming that Porcelain Black is the "next Lady Gaga," I think Gaga's done with him. After he shaded her on Twitter, or was it Porcelain, she showed up in Taiwan with Porcelain's hairstyle (her subtle way of throwing shade).

As much as I personally love his tracks on BTW, they are completely uninspired and overrated. 'Scheisse' could have been so much more.

Then again, he gave me the masterpiece 'Hair', so I can't complain too much.

Scheiße is perfection tbh.

[Ouz]

I personally LOVE Scheiße and really like Judas. So I don't have problems with him working with her.
We also discussed this before the BTW album, you know JLo's Love? and stuff. Gaga gets the good stuff -cause she has full control over the process- so no worries.

[Boop]

But why she must work with the same producer(s)? I hope for a change... not a radical one but almost

[RobynYoBank]

Originally posted by Riverwide

RedOne's work with GaGa has always been vastly superior to his work with other artists. I see no reason to think that would change. She's not about to release songs that sound like JLS or Enrique. She gets the best out of him always.

I certainly don't think RedOne's work stands out from the rest of the work on this album. I think the best 3 songs on the album are GH, HML and BTW, none of which have his name attached.

[Christian]

Originally posted by Anthagio

I think i'm just biased and pissed off at his "PB is the next LG" comments. xD

It was off-putting for sure. I think he just said it a la "this will be the album of the decade" mood.

[Anthagio]

Originally posted by Symphonic

Scheiße is perfection tbh.

But do you feel like something is missing? When hearing its remix at the Mugler show, I was so sure the song was going to be flawless, but after hearing the full version, I was left with a "that's it" feeling, you know what I mean?

Originally posted by Ouz

I personally LOVE Schieße and really like Judas. So I don't have problems with him working with her.
We also discussed this before the BTW album, you know JLo's Love? and stuff. Gaga gets the good stuff -cause she has full control over the process- so no worries.

'Judas' is perfection to me, even if it does sound like 'Bad Romance'. Her creative input is def. one of the reasons why her music is so good.

Originally posted by RobynYoBank

I certainly don't think RedOne's work stands out from the rest of the work on this album. I think the best 3 songs on the album are GH, HML and BTW, none of which have his name attached.

I think the fact that it doesn't stand out says something, you know? His work on TFM seemed so good because he was the main producer, but putting him up against DJWS and FG really shows that he's not all that great and there are better.

Originally posted by Boop

But why she must work with the same producer(s)? I hope for a change... not a radical one but almost

I agree. I would still like FG to stick around.

[Symphonic]

Originally posted by Anthagio

But do you feel like something is missing? When hearing its remix at the Mugler show, I was so sure the song was going to be flawless, but after hearing the full version, I was left with a "that's it" feeling, you know what I mean?

I felt the opposite, it surprised me (in a good way) a lot as I'd been paying attention to the Government Hooker remix much more than the Scheiße remix.

[Navin]

Originally posted by Symphonic

Scheiße is perfection tbh.

Exactly. Thats why I still want 1 or 2 tracks by him because there is always 1 standout when they work together !

Originally posted by Anthagio

But do you feel like something is missing? When hearing its remix at the Mugler show, I was so sure the song was going to be flawless, but after hearing the full version, I was left with a "that's it" feeling, you know what I mean?

I actually think the album version ***** on the Remix.
Its the other way around with Hooker though.

[Anthagio]

Originally posted by Symphonic

I felt the opposite, it surprised me (in a good way) a lot as I'd been paying attention to the Government Hooker remix much more than the Scheiße remix.

I felt the same way about GH, too, which sucks 'cause I was expecting them to be the best songs on the album. Maybe I hyped myself up too much. After all, the remix only used the best parts of the song.

[Symphonic]

Originally posted by Anthagio

I felt the same way about GH, too, which sucks 'cause I was expecting them to be the best songs on the album. Maybe I hyped myself up too much. After all, the remix only used the best parts of the song.

Everyone always says the Mugler GH was much better than the studio version, but I like the studio version much better and the bass/instrumental is amazing. Scheiße and Government Hooker are both in the top 5 tracks on the album for me.

[Ouz]

I absolutely prefer the album versions over the Mugler remixes. Both Scheiße + Government Hooker.

[Ginger.]

Originally posted by Ouz

I absolutely prefer the album versions over the Mugler remixes. Both Scheiße + Government Hooker.

Tea spilled.

[Gagasm]

Originally posted by Ouz

I absolutely prefer the album versions over the Mugler remixes. Both Scheiße + Government Hooker.

People prefer that over the original Scheisse?

[Peep]

Album Scheiße >>>

Only the intro is a bit too long.

[Ginger.]

Originally posted by Gagasm

People prefer that over the original Scheisse?

I'm certainly not here for a remix of a song that is 99.2954523458% gibberish/not even German.

[Drowned_World]

Originally posted by Gagasm

People prefer that over the original Scheisse?

I used to. Not anymore.

[ddeizaguirre]

I think scheibe is amazing the instrumental is perfection but the message is weak IMO I think it'll still smash hard though! Judas has grown on me amazing track somewhat comical to me or maybe the video gives me that feel... Hair is ****ing epic best redone track on the album hands down! Great message great instrumental a mixture of 80s rock ballad with metal in the structure of a pop song which is awesome and the bridge slays! I would like for the, to continue working together at least 2 songs per album.. Hes the piece of the puzzle that made her who she is and losing him so soon might not be a good idea.. I must agree his recent non gaga tracks are absolutely horrible! So disappointed in him recycled trash after recycled trash..

[Drowned_World]

Originally posted by Navin

Im hoping she uses more White Shadow, and makes Fernando a co producer so he can leave his touch.

Me too!
I also hope she'll work with Bloodshy & Avant, Chase and Status and maybe Space Cowboy on the next record.

[Ginger.]

Originally posted by ddeizaguirre

I think scheibe is amazing the instrumental is perfection but the message is weak IMO I think it'll still smash hard though! Judas has grown on me amazing track somewhat comical to me or maybe the video gives me that feel... Hair is ****ing epic best redone track on the album hands down! Great message great instrumental a mixture of 80s rock ballad with metal in the structure of a pop song which is awesome and the bridge slays! I would like for the, to continue working together at least 2 songs per album.. Hes the piece of the puzzle that made her who she is and losing him so soon might not be a good idea.. I must agree his recent non gaga tracks are absolutely horrible! So disappointed in him recycled trash after recycled trash..