His poem was the most creative and I love the content. I don't think it should've been judged just because it's short, because even though clarity isn't there, the judges was left hanging for what it's meant to be, and I think he got me impressed with that. But well, of course, it's just my opinion.
I really don't like this challenge for some reason... (probably 'cause it's about one artist unlike the other challenges...)
That definitely makes sense, but this challenge is about being in tune with today's pop music. While Adele doesn't solely represent today's pop, she's arguably been the biggest name in Pop this year, and part of being on ATRL requires being able to keep up, to an extent, with musical trends.
However, the challenge may focus on Adele, but it's not about her. It's about you.