[fanoftalent]

Originally posted by MonsterRoco

She basic thats why, her back catalog has some nice songs, but she's been rehashing them for years.

She is the most generic pop star out there.

After Britney.

[fanoftalent]

Originally posted by Cap10Planet

I actually brought up this topic because I saw the Pepsi commercial of Britney, Beyonce and Pink.

Its funny how she owns that one

[Duca]

Originally posted by fanoftalent

Its funny how she owns that one

After Britney.

[Michael]

fanoftalent that's 5 posts in a row, you POST-*****.

[fanoftalent]

Originally posted by satellites™

When this thread is discussed and done, the Trinity will still be seen as Beyonce, Britney, and Gaga and always will be because they are the first and will be the last.

If no one can ever be the new Queen or King of Pop, then no one can ever be the new Trinity.

Oh sweetie, you can keep your trinity. My fave don't associate with flops

[nky0411]

many are mad of Gaga as one of the trinity .. =.=

She achieved a level of success others can only achieve in more than 6 years.
And trinity can be constantly updated, so i don't think there is anything wrong.

[fanoftalent]

Originally posted by Duca

After Britney.

Sorry but Britney with all her star power was the weakest link in that video. Even Beyonce, who did R'n'B **** in a rock song did much better than her. Britney was very out of place and her voice as always underwhelming.

[fanoftalent]

All Beyonce hate aside, I do like her and I find it amusing/surprising how her stans are wiling to group her with Britney and GaGa. Her stans must be insecure and not too confident in her to be content with placing her along with other two. I don't have much against the other two either, but Beyonce is on another level compared to brit and gaga when it comes to musical artistry and industry respect.

[Chemist]

Originally posted by fanoftalent

All Beyonce hate aside, I do like her and I find it amusing/surprising how her stans are wiling to group her with Britney and GaGa. Her stans must be insecure and not too confident in her to be content with placing her along with other two. I don't have much against the other two either, but Beyonce is on another level compared to brit and gaga when it comes to musical artistry and industry respect.

Well, they rather have her next to Britney and Gaga than next to anything Pink related, so...

[slobro]

Gaga despite her short three years has all the receipts necessary

Massive album sales
Massive singles
Very talented singer/musician/songwriter/performer
The Monster Ball is one of top grossing tours of ALL TIME, achieved in less than three years
Massive star power
Biggest female pop phenomenon since forever
Massive dedicated fanbase
Contemporaries and even many legends and icons praising her
A workshop dedicated to her
An university study dedicated to her, really, who else

Gaga's receipts are undeniable, no other pop diva comes close. But even if Gaga didn't exist, Rihanna probably would've been in this 'trinity' before P!nk anyways, because no one cares about her

[fanoftalent]

Originally posted by slobro

Gaga despite her short three years has all the receipts necessary

Massive album sales
Massive singles
Very talented singer/musician/songwriter/performer
The Monster Ball is one of top grossing tours of ALL TIME, achieved in less than three years
Massive star power
Biggest female pop phenomenon since forever
Massive dedicated fanbase
Contemporaries and even many legends and icons praising her
A workshop dedicated to her
An university study dedicated to her, really, who else

Gaga's receipts are undeniable, no other pop diva comes close. But even if Gaga didn't exist, Rihanna probably would've been in this 'trinity' before P!nk anyways, because no one cares about her

You forgot to add that she's a carbon copy of Madonna. Never seen a pop artist imitating another one so perfectly

[Chrïs.]

Originally posted by slobro

Gaga despite her short three years has all the receipts necessary

Massive album sales
Massive singles
Very talented singer/musician/songwriter/performer
The Monster Ball is one of top grossing tours of ALL TIME, achieved in less than three years
Massive star power
Biggest female pop phenomenon since forever
Massive dedicated fanbase
Contemporaries and even many legends and icons praising her
A workshop dedicated to her
An university study dedicated to her, really, who else

Gaga's receipts are undeniable, no other pop diva comes close. But even if Gaga didn't exist, Rihanna probably would've been in this 'trinity' before P!nk anyways, because no one cares about her

You also forgot -- She has a #1 album.

[slobro]

Originally posted by fanoftalent

You forgot to add that she's a carbon copy of Madonna. Never seen a pop artist imitating another one so perfectly

I see you also forgetting that Pink was flopping until she started swagger jacking Kelly Clarkson's pop/rock sound, even going as far hiring the exact same producers

[Michael]

Originally posted by slobro

I see you also forgetting that Pink was flopping until she started swagger jacking Kelly Clarkson's pop/rock sound, even going as far hiring the exact same producers

Umm no. Can't Take Me Home sold over 4m worldwide - not a flop. And Kelly Clarkson debuted in 2003, after P!nk had already adopted the pop-rock sound.

[fanoftalent]

Originally posted by slobro

I see you also forgetting that Pink was flopping until she started swagger jacking Kelly Clarkson's pop/rock sound, even going as far hiring the exact same producers

She was doing pop/rock first but ok. Even if she was imitating somebody, she couldn't reach the same level as GaGa when it comes to copying.

[Venus]

I think Pink's biggest downfall is that she appears to have a hipster/indie mentality when she's a popstar.

[Louie]

Originally posted by Duca

After Britney.

DRAGGED.

[Lose My Breath]

You guys are missing the entire point of the three selected..

They have all built an EMPIRE, a brand.. Their name alone can sell anything whether it be perfume, music, movies, clothes...(etc)

The others mentioned in this thread have not, they don't have the star power....not yet anyway!

Rhianna, Katy, (Insert Pop Starlet Name Here) haven't built their brand, their power.


Oh, and you can't count Beyonce out of this considering she was just named the most powerful black woman by Forbes, why anyone would considering replacing her is amusing at most...

[ashuduff]

People only care about P!nk's music - she doesn't have Madonna's and Gaga's shock factor, Janet's moves and famous family, Mariah's and Britney's meltdowns....

[Duca]

Originally posted by Chris101

You also forgot -- She has a #1 album.

And also a #1 debut single.