[Vulps]

Originally posted by slobro

Goodbye Lullaby isn't commercial? We're talking about the album where the three first singles are catchy Max Martin produced pop candy right?

Three out of fourteen tracks. So no.

[Squall]

Originally posted by slobro

Goodbye Lullaby isn't commercial? We're talking about the album where the three first singles are catchy Max Martin produced pop candy right?

WTH & Smile doesn't represent GL at all, they have not their place on this album and that's RCA who chose these singles (that's why I said RCA wasted the exploitation, and moreover, Avril didn't want hese songs) so this is bad choices.
Anyway, I love Gaga so I'm still happy for her success.
We'll see how she sell with the next albums.

[_DeviouS_]

Originally posted by MrVulps

Three out of fourteen tracks. So no.

Avril? EW.

[danielgri17]

i can't with all this delusional avril fans , that are mad because japan, avril's biggest market, has been taken by gaga

[Squall]

Originally posted by danielgri17

i can't with all this delusional avril fans , that are mad because japan, avril's biggest market, has been taken by gaga

Not yet maybe one day but you can't say this now.

[LostInStereo100]

Originally posted by Squall

WTH & Smile doesn't represent GL at all, they have not their place on this album and that's RCA who chose these singles (that's why I said RCA wasted the exploitation, and moreover, Avril didn't want hese songs) so this is bad choices.
Anyway, I love Gaga so I'm still happy for her success.
We'll see how she sell with the next albums.

That's Exactly What Everyone Was Saying About "Born This Way"

"we'll see what BTW will sell"

Anways I Love Avril Her First Two Albums SLAYED, While Her Last Two Were Just OK

IMO

[Vulps]

Originally posted by _DeviouS_

Avril is commercial. Shut up.

Originally posted by _DeviouS_

Avril? EW.

You should take your valuable contributions elsewhere.

[Squall]

Originally posted by Lost_In_Stereo100

That's Exactly What Everyone Was Saying About "Born This Way"

"we'll see what BTW will sell"

Anways I Love Avril But Her First Two Albums SLAYED, While Her Last Two Were Just OK

IMO

Please, for 3 years, we've always seen Gaga, the promo is huge.
And 1M just ok?Lol

[ZimsexZim]

Queen of Asia indeed

[LeMews]

Ruling Asia atm
The delusion in this thread is so entertaining.

[LostInStereo100]

Originally posted by Squall

Please, for 3 years, we've always seen Gaga, the promo is huge.
And 1M just ok?Lol

Japan LOVES Avril

All Im Trying To Say Is GAGA Is BIGGER At The Moment. Monumentally (probably not even a word) Larger.

But Right Now

Japan LOVES Gaga More. It Seems Like, Sorry

[Nicole]

This thread is old and the stats are now outdated and inaccurate: http://atrl.net/forums/showthread.php?t=139915

[Navin]

Originally posted by Squall

Not yet maybe one day but you can't say this now.

Gagas latest album has sold 100k more than GL so far & its still going strong.
Avrils market is gone.

[UAE]

Some Avirl fans are just ......

Really BTW is Commercial .... and goodbye lullaby isn't

[Squall]

Originally posted by Haus Of Navin

Gagas latest album has sold 100k more than GL so far & its still going strong.
Avrils market is gone.

If we consider this (I saif IF) like a flop, when you flop it's not over. But after 4 years of absence and with this promo, this label and this album, it's pretty good for her.

[Vulps]

Originally posted by Haus Of Navin

Gagas latest album has sold 100k more than GL so far & its still going strong.
Avrils market is gone.

That doesn't mean her market is gone though. o_O

[RatedG²]

Originally posted by Haus_of_Nicole

This thread is old and the stats are now outdated and inaccurate: http://atrl.net/forums/showthread.php?t=139915

So there is no reason to keep this thread

[RandomHooker]

Originally posted by MrVulps

Three out of fourteen tracks. So no.

Well the 'public' doesn't know about the fourteen other tracks, the three singles ARE << catchy Max Martin produced pop candies >>. They are commercial.

[RandomHooker]

Originally posted by Haus_of_Nicole

Are people here mentally retarded from birth, or as a result of an experience?

What the **** is commercial about BTW?

2 years ago the bitch was singing about dancing in the club and riding dick...now she's put out an album full of religious, social, political messages. Even her "safe" first 4 singles are about being gay, religion, death, and a ballad.

This is as RISKY a pop album as it gets, especially from a major pop star. The other girls are never, ever, EVER risking it like this. EVER.

that's what I call 'Faire le ménage' !

[Squall]

Originally posted by RandomHooker

Well the 'public' doesn't know about the fourteen other tracks, the three singles ARE << catchy Max Martin produced pop candies >>. They are commercial.

We didn't say that Martin's songs were not commercial (except I Love You....).