[huycaptan]

IT'S BRITNEY BITCH 1 SHE APPEAR

[Jake.]

An abomination compared to the song.

[Bad Wolf]

The set reminds me of Sesame Street

[JRtheMonster]

-

[JRtheMonster]

The Born This Way video ended with Gaga in the smokey streets of NY.
The Edge of Glory video begins right where that left off.

[MrPeanut]

Originally posted by Rainbows

The set reminds me of Sesame Street

They should have just had Oscar the Grouch do the sax solo and be done with it.

[Harry]

I ****ing knew it

[huycaptan]

Omggggggg , i dieeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee.

[Edi_Shak]

Originally posted by Hilary & Rock

This girl is CRAZYYY!!!
but she's funny

[BTrisc]

Originally posted by MrPeanut

At least BDR, in all its terribleness, has swagger in spades. This is lifeless, totally lifeless.

Ok Negative Nance. While this video had a lot of potential, it's not nearly as bad as Gaga stans are exaggerating it to be.

[huycaptan]

liveeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee

[ChrisGagers]

The public is going to love this video though.

Look, if this song was about your grandpa dying would you want some fishyness in it?

She did was she felt like was right.

Im just honestly surprised how much say she really does have in everything. To just drop the original set and plan like that is ludacris. If it were another basic bitch her management would have been like...WTF? bitch sit down.

I give the video a B-. It could have been alot better though just with her having dancers and jumping off the roof in the end into her grandfathers arms or something.

[huycaptan]

3 LIVEEEEEEEEEEEEEE

[uhton]

It's worst video ever...
I hate this.
It's not Gaga...

[MrPeanut]

Originally posted by BTrisc0392

Ok Negative Nance. While this video had a lot of potential, it's not nearly as bad as Gaga stans are exaggerating it to be.

I'm just giving my honest opinion.

I'd be the first to tell you I don't find unbridled pessimism to be any more realistic than the other extreme of unwavering worship, but it is what it is in this case, for me.

[JRtheMonster]

CONCEPT OF TEOG VID:
FREEDOM
She showed us what is like to be free or how to be free since we're on the Edge Of Our Glory, Being free is like no one to tell u that u can't be who u want to be (GAGA HERSELF RUNNING AROUND THE STREETS OF NEW YORK,
GAGA COMING OUT OF THE WINDOW)
You can do whatever you want (DANCING AROUND THE BUILDING)
Remembering where u came from (KISSING THE SIDEWALK)
HER STATE OF BEING WHEN SHE TRIED TO BE FREE (Gaga going up(good times) and down (bad times) to the stairs) and at the end GAGA ENTERS INSIDE THE WINDOW OF HER APARTMENT (whenever we want to be free we can go to her all the time it's like gaga inviting us to come with her since she's alone in the video)













...

[Tantei]

So..I have to admit it's so booooring
After Judas being an expensive music video I think this is the cheapest in pop history

[Tantei]

Originally posted by JRtheMonster

CONCEPT OF TEOG VID:
FREEDOM
She showed us what is like to be free or how to be free since we're on the Edge Of Our Glory, Being free is like no one to tell u that u can't be who u want to be (GAGA HERSELF RUNNING AROUND THE STREETS OF NEW YORK,
GAGA COMING OUT OF THE WINDOW)
You can do whatever you want (DANCING AROUND THE BUILDING)
Remembering where u came from (KISSING THE SIDEWALK)
HER STATE OF BEING WHEN SHE TRIED TO BE FREE (Gaga going up(good times) and down (bad times) to the stairs) and at the end GAGA ENTERS INSIDE THE WINDOW OF HER APARTMENT (whenever we want to be free we can go to her all the time it's like gaga inviting us to come with her since she's alone in the video)













...

I don't think that's true...I think they messed up the filming..and that's probably all the stuff they had...I don't see a meaning in this video..

[BTrisc]

Originally posted by MrPeanut

I'm just giving my honest opinion.

I'd be the first to tell you I don't find unbridled pessimism to be any more realistic than the other extreme of unwavering worship, but it is what it is in this case, for me.

I believe you.

The video inevitably was lazy. Very lazy. If the song didn't have a preexisting celebration theme, this video would be a bonafide flop. But it does, so there is some gratification from seeing Gaga humping poles and licking the ground in celebration. It's better for her to do an overly simple video than a far-reaching video with cryptic metaphors, IMO. The only parts that bother me are the terrible camera angles and edits at some parts.

[Harry]

The first half is boring as **** I can't even spell it out, but it goes uphill after that. The final quarter of the video is the best and very fascinating. However, I still can't get my hand on the overall concept of the video. What is she trying to capture here actually? Lady Gaga herself dancing and dressing like a stripper at a house balcony, and sometimes surrounded by gay dancers who aren't even dancing?

She didn't obey the max of 3 secs per scene, this is where it gets really boring, it's like watching her live performance. I love the dark back alley theme here, but using it to film the whole music video? That's ****ing stupid and ridiculous. She should have inserted a little element of diversity and storyline. Easily her worst, I don't expect much of a push on charts with such crappy video.

Her arrogance is backfiring her.