[thegmangrant]

Originally posted by Mąni Lιn`Dεε

No, but I don't consider them terrible songs either. I love all Britney, Lady Gaga, & Katy Perry songs because I have a very versatile taste in music, meaning I can rock out anything so it doesn't matter to me, but if terrible means "top 10" status then please keep it up! Beyonce appreciates it honey

I can believe that you have versatile tastes in music, but I have a hard time believing you like every song to enter the iTunes Top 10.

I'm not saying the song is terrible because it is top ten. I'm just not seeing your logic by saying the song is good because it is the top ten on iTunes.


The song isn't as terrible as I thought it was when I first heard it (mostly because I love Pon De Floor). But the song is still borderline boring and lacking in something. Very underwhelmed. Because I really liked some uptempo songs by Beyonce such as Radio, Single Ladies, Diva, and of course my favorite Beyonce song Sweet Dreams.

[BeamMeUp]

Originally posted by BTrisc0392

No, it's all good. I mean, we monsters just had that Judas mess on Friday.

But now you all understand why we got angry! Whenever people come for the baddest girls in the business, we have to get into ultra stan mode.

I'm liking this song though, I wanted to hate it because you all went gung ho hating on Judas/Gaga, but I'm gonna be a better person and bridge the gap.

I like Judas

[thegmangrant]

Originally posted by satellites™

I dont even think thats it, I think she released this as the first single because she knows it will be successful as a lead rather than as a 2nd or 3rd single.

Honestly the song belongs as just an album track.... on the deluxe edition of the CD

[YoYo]

They make some good points. The song is not the typical Beyonce track so I was estranged at first, but it's really growing on me

Originally posted by Chemist

I am confident that the video will make the song like SL

That's a bad thing IMO. A woman of her talent shouldn't rely on videos to make the song likable.

[Wilkes]

Beyonce stans were so quick to dismiss other lead singles but when their fave underwhelms the song is suddenly unique.

[Radio Phone]

Originally posted by thegmangrant

You're right, I wish that Britney could be so different, unique, and edgy by using the beat to another song Beyonce is such an example for not taking the easy route with her music

There's nothing wrong with being inspired by another song. If she wants to play off Pon de Floor, that's fine as long as she makes it her own, and she did, point blank end of story.

I'm not going to make a comment about Britney and Out from Under.

[Barbarella]

Originally posted by fabbriche

CNN is right. But quite expectedly, the Grammy will overrate this song again.

No more than Rolling Stones and that infamous list.

[skyler]

the hate thats in this thread

[GeezusHaberdash]

In the end, it might have more in common "with left-field pop icons like Grace Jones and Yoko Ono than with arguable peers like Rihanna or Mariah Carey."

Avant-gardé

[thegmangrant]

Originally posted by Radio Phone

There's nothing wrong with being inspired by another song. If she wants to play off Pon de Floor, that's fine as long as she makes it her own, and she did, point blank end of story.

I'm not going to make a comment about Britney and Out from Under.

She covered the song. She did not claim it as her own, nor did she release it as a single. So I fail to see your point. I'll still reporting you though for flamebait

I don't mind her being "inspired", although I am disappointed that she didn't do something more creative when I heard rumors a week or two ago that she was "sampling" the song. Also it's annoying how you all take jabs at our faves and say that Beyonce is being innovative and unique when she isn't. She took a beat to another song and pasted it into hers. It's the same producer so it makes it better, but still... it's not that original...

[Radio Phone]

Originally posted by Haus of Wilke$

Beyonce stans were so quick to dismiss other lead singles but when their fave underwhelms the song is suddenly unique.

Fool we knew it was going to be unique to begin with due to the numerous reports before the song was even released.

[CaptainMusic]

Originally posted by Haus of Wilke$

Beyonce stans were so quick to dismiss other lead singles but when their fave underwhelms the song is suddenly unique.

Arent you a beyonce stan too,I thought you had a beyonce pic as your avatar yesterday when you commented in the femme fatale? Or maybe im confusing you with someone.

[Wilkes]

Originally posted by Radio Phone

Fool we knew it was going to be unique to begin with due to the numerous reports before the song was even released.

Fool?

It is unique in all the wrong ways.

[Wilkes]

Originally posted by CaptainMusic

Arent you a beyonce stan too,I thought you had a beyonce pic as your avatar yesterday when you commented in the femme fatale? Or maybe im confusing you with someone.

I am, but that doesn't mean I can't make a generalization of the stanbase as a whole.

[thegmangrant]

Originally posted by Haus of Wilke$

Fool?

It is unique in all the wrong ways.

It isn't unique

[CaptainMusic]

Originally posted by Haus of Wilke$

I am, but that doesn't mean I can't make a generalization of the stanbase as a whole.

oh ok

[Radio Phone]

Originally posted by thegmangrant

She covered the song. She did not claim it as her own, nor did she release it as a single. So I fail to see your point. I'll still reporting you though for flamebait

I don't mind her being "inspired", although I am disappointed that she didn't do something more creative when I heard rumors a week or two ago that she was "sampling" the song. Also it's annoying how you all take jabs at our faves and say that Beyonce is being innovative and unique when she isn't. She took a beat to another song and pasted it into hers. It's the same producer so it makes it better, but still... it's not that original...[/QUOTE]Yes you do see my point. I will **** on your report because I care about it even less than [edited. let me try to keep it cute.]

She made it her own, completely. This song was a successful step towards innovativeness and there's still the rest of the album to listen to before you get too slick mouthed judging her progress this time around off of a single song. Sit down, you're done.

[Wilkes]

Originally posted by thegmangrant

It isn't unique

The beat is not unique, what is unique is the odd structure and odd tribal vocals.

[CaptainMusic]

Originally posted by Radio Phone

Yes you do see my point. I will **** on your report because I care about it even less than Britney cares about her kids. Now report that.

Bitch, do not bring britney up in here.

[Radio Phone]

Originally posted by CaptainMusic

Bitch, do not bring britney up in here.

They're trying it.