[Green Boy]

Originally posted by skyler_

do you want to take this to SYG, lets not talk about Janet

hey who do you really stan for?

[alstrom]

What's this mess?

[Cap10Planet]

The same people who are saying "Judas" will go #1 are probably the same ones who said "Bad Romance" would go #1.

I'll just wait and see what happens because stans pimp stuff way too much.

[clairebear23]

Originally posted by L/\DY G/\G/\

Automatic
Glad Kelly is getting some success but I would rather it be with her other songs (Rose Colored Glases, Shake Them Haters Off, etc.)

Kelly was released? *purchases*

[staracademy1990]

Originally posted by RobynYoBank

Well, Judas already seems to have an army of listeners/reviewers who think the song with smash.

Judas is getting treatment similar to that of Born This Way in terms of immediate radio support. Everyone knows about its release.

Let's not forget that Gaga is a colossus of sorts right now. No one has any idea what her songs sound like, they haven't leaked any everyone wants to hear more. She has one of the two most powerful fanbases in the world. She will have the immediate power regardless of what the song sounds like simply because she has people interested. Judas will explode upon arrival. The second, third, fourth, fifth, etc. will determine how its received.

I'm sure people outside this forum, like regular non-stans don't know about Judas' existence

Originally posted by Chris101

You have a point. But, big releases like Girl / Judas / Hold It Against Me / Born This Way / Only Girl.. will sell big first week for several reasons. (Hype, big fan bases...)
Of course, if a song is actually good / bad, it will sell better / worse.
That's just my opinion.

I kindda agree, but it bothers me that it's not the song (quality music) selling anymore, it's basically the artist with the bigger stanbase. It's sad to see what music has come into

[Chrïs.]

Originally posted by clairebear23

The world was just introduced to the Brihmix. I think Brit's team would want her to be present for promotion also Rihanna began tour rehearsals two days ago. Maybe S&M was first? Guess well see. Theres so much secrecy about this appearance.

Originally posted by RudeBoy

Not the remix, featuring BRITNEY SPEARS..

Oh, I see. Hopefully she performs with Britney.

[staracademy1990]

ok who reported this thread? you guys realize that if this is shut down ya'll have no place to discuss iTunes chart positions, so let's keep it cute in here

if you wanna argue or defend your faves honor, take it to SYG

[skyler]

Originally posted by Green Boy

hey who do you really stan for?

look whos in my sig thats who I stan for

[Яeo.]

Originally posted by staracademy1990

Ya'll are just messed up, you say Judas will go number one because BTW was very successful when released? that's what I call fail logic.

It won't go #1 because the song is good, neither because of BTW. It will go #1 because it's Lady GaGa. It is too hyped to not go #1.

[Chrïs.]

Originally posted by staracademy1990

I kindda agree, but it bothers me that it's not the song (quality music) selling anymore, it's basically the artist with the bigger stanbase. It's sad to see what music has come into

You're right. But the fan base can only help in the 1st weeks, not in the long run.

[Cap10Planet]

Originally posted by RudeBoy

It won't go #1 because the song is good, neither because of BTW. It will go #1 because it's Lady GaGa. It is too hyped to not go #1.

If it doesn't hit #1, would it be considered a "failure?"

[The Ri-son!]

Originally posted by staracademy1990

New Releases: Singles

US
2. S&M (Remix) - Rihanna featuring Britney Spears
38. Automatic - Aubrey O'Day
41. Red Nation (feat. Lil Wayne) - Game
55. Motivation (feat. Lil Wayne) - Kelly Rowland
255. Make Some Noise - Beastie Boys

CAN
135. Red Nation (feat. Lil Wayne) - Game
136. Make Some Noise - Beastie Boys
222. Motivation (feat. Lil Wayne) - Kelly Rowland
598. Automatic - Aubrey O'Day

yes kelly and aubrey are punching

[The Ri-son!]

who reported the itunes thread????? what tired poor soul would do that???

[guga10]

Originally posted by RudeBoy

It won't go #1 because the song is good, neither because of BTW. It will go #1 because it's Lady GaGa. It is too hyped to not go #1.

You are assuming without hearing the song that the song is not good and it will only reach number 1 because is GaGa?

Well, everyone agrees the BTW was not the best song in the world and it did sell because it was GaGa but u shouldn`t assume the same about Judas.

[guga10]

Originally posted by Cap10Planet

If it doesn't hit #1, would it be considered a "failure?"

Do you consider Bad Romance a "failure"? I don`t...

[Chrïs.]

Originally posted by Cap10Planet

If it doesn't hit #1, would it be considered a "failure?"

Not in my dictionary, because sales / longevity / impact >>> #1s.

[Яeo.]

Originally posted by guga10

You are assuming without hearing the song that the song is not good and it will only reach number 1 because is GaGa?

Well, everyone agrees the BTW was not the best song in the world and it did sell because it was GaGa but u shouldn`t assume the same about Judas.

I never said that. I said that the main reason Judas will go #1 after its release on iTunes isn't because of how good the song is (Didn't say it's bad), but mainly because of Lady GaGa.

[Stepfon]

I want Aubrey to go Top 20, she deserves it and so much more.

[MrPeanut]

Originally posted by clairebear23

Sweetie, dont pay any Gaga fans any attention. They hated ET, now theyre using ET as a scapegoat bc they want it to block SM and from Rihanna landing her 10th #1 and Brit her 5th.

[

Aww, what a cute little bit of revisionist history. Actually, if you would remember correctly, most Gaga fans seemed to have a positive opinion of E.T. (even vozas, who constantly trolled against Katy, liked it), whereas it was certain Rihanna stans (such as yourself) who were miffed that it was blocking S&M from the top spot.

I don't want S&M to be blocked, I'd just like for people to acknowledge when they're being hypocritical, but I know I won't be holding my breath on that one, since some people would rather just play coy and post the same .gif over and over as if it was helping their case.

[guga10]

Originally posted by RudeBoy

I never said that. I said that the main reason Judas will go #1 after its release on iTunes isn't because of how good the song is (Didn't say it's bad), but mainly because of Lady GaGa.

Ahhh ok, i undestood it wrong. I actually agree with you and i think that`sthe good thing about low hype. It will go #1 on Itunes because is GaGa but because of no hype it will only stay there if it`s good, especially after BTW...