[Tutankhamun]

Mariah remains the biggest artist and no one who debuted after her has surpassed her. I was just watching her new show and went through her discography and wooo she DID THAT. She was so huge back in my childhood years (the 90s) and I feel like atrl is criminally underrating her.

[Wicked]

Wish I could've experienced the 90s run.

But commercially, Eminem is on her neck. Hasn't he already reached 200m records?

[Lifeline]

I didn't know her in my childhood tho. OK

[OpenBacardi]

Wow I've never looked at it like that. What a legend, Eminem is the closest but with the decline of sales I don't think he will surpass Mariah.

[Breakdown]

Exactly. There's just no one with that amount of talent that came after her.
Taylor is the closest but she won't reach ha success.

[Rei]

With numbers alone no one will because sales have declined.

Taking everything into account multiple popgirls have surpassed her since.

[Wicked]

Originally posted by OpenBacardi

Wow I've never looked at it like that. What a legend, Eminem is the closest but with the decline of sales I don't think he will surpass Mariah.

His receipts thread says 290M records.

[Tutankhamun]

Originally posted by Rei

Taking everything into account multiple popgirls have surpassed her since.

like who? elaborate.

[OpenBacardi]

Originally posted by Wicked

His receipts thread says 290M records.

And Mariah's one says 365M+ records

[Pecinta Mariah]

now that you mentioned it

[Wicked]

Originally posted by OpenBacardi

And Mariah's one says 365M+ records

It says 220M when I just looked at it.

http://atrl.net/forums/showthread.php?t=287060

365M doesn't even sound realistic.

[sweetheart]

True, but she had eclipsed Sandra.

[Eternium]

Very few females hold this honor. Madonna, Celine, Mariah, Britney, Taylor and Adele

I was just listening to Side Effects, Migrate, H.A.T.E.U. and Bye Bye!

[Pristine]

Originally posted by Rei

With numbers alone no one will because sales have declined.

Taking everything into account multiple popgirls have surpassed her since.

Mariah's star power and legendary status has not really been surpassed, even if she had sold a lot less and had less No1s there is almost no star since can rival her superstar status.

[Fruity]

Originally posted by Pristine

Mariah's star power and legendary status has not really been surpassed, even if she had sold a lot less and had less No1s there is almost no star since can rival her superstar status.

Beyonce has easily surpassed Mariah in superstar status and Rihanna has in singles success.

[LoveLiveMusic]

Like all her singles that actually charted to the end of 1999 landed no less than Top 15 in the US.

[stevyy]

Originally posted by Fruity

Beyonce has easily surpassed Mariah in superstar status and Rihanna has in singles success.

she has not. Mariah had the #1 song in the world on sales and streaming on DEC 24th 2016, she currently ranks top 15 in 18 national singles charts + Belgium (at the age of 46).

#1 - Belgium
#3 - Netherlands
#3 - Norway
#3 - Portugal
#4 - Denmark
#4 - France
#5 - United Kingdom
#5 - Ireland
#5 - Switzerland
#7 - Sweden
#10 - Germany
#10 - Czech Republic
#11 - Canada
#12 - Austria
#12 - United States
#13 - Slovakia
#15 - Australia
#16 - New Zealand

come back when Beyoncé has a global smash single at the age of 46. Og wait she's struggling even now to get her music to the people.

Merrier Xmas has sold 10,179 copies this week in the United States which brings its total for 2016 to 46,000 in just the 7 weeks it made the BB 200 soundscan chart, it has peaked at #28 on the BB200 and sold 115,000 in SPS copies.

[swissman]

Originally posted by stevyy

she has not. Mariah had the #1 song in the world on sales and streaming on DEC 24th 2016, she currently ranks top 15 in 18 national singles charts + Belgium (at the age of 46).

#1 - Belgium
#3 - Netherlands
#3 - Norway
#3 - Portugal
#4 - Denmark
#4 - France
#5 - United Kingdom
#5 - Ireland
#5 - Switzerland
#7 - Sweden
#10 - Germany
#10 - Czech Republic
#11 - Canada
#12 - Austria
#12 - United States
#13 - Slovakia
#15 - Australia
#16 - New Zealand

come back when Beyoncé has a global smash single at the age of 46. Og wait she's struggling even now to get her music to the people.

Merrier Xmas has sold 10,179 copies this week in the United States which brings its total for 2016 to 46,000 in just the 7 weeks it made the BB 200 soundscan chart, it has peaked at #28 on the BB200 and sold 115,000 in SPS copies.

19 years into her career Beyoncé has the #1 tour of the year with only 49 dates!

And the actual struggle is not for Beyoncé to get her music to the people, considering that she has its streams locked on TIDAL, it's biggest hit released for 3 months free, all subsequent singles having 0 promotion and is still the best selling female album of the year.

And I love Mariah but let’s not pretend like this song’s success isn’t because of Christmas and nostalgia. It's one of the greatest Christmas songs of all time. It's going to do well ever year, and it should!

[OffTheWall]

True

[Touchdown]

Originally posted by stevyy

she has not. Mariah had the #1 song in the world on sales and streaming on DEC 24th 2016, she currently ranks top 15 in 18 national singles charts + Belgium (at the age of 46).

#1 - Belgium
#3 - Netherlands
#3 - Norway
#3 - Portugal
#4 - Denmark
#4 - France
#5 - United Kingdom
#5 - Ireland
#5 - Switzerland
#7 - Sweden
#10 - Germany
#10 - Czech Republic
#11 - Canada
#12 - Austria
#12 - United States
#13 - Slovakia
#15 - Australia
#16 - New Zealand

come back when Beyoncé has a global smash single at the age of 46. Og wait she's struggling even now to get her music to the people.

Merrier Xmas has sold 10,179 copies this week in the United States which brings its total for 2016 to 46,000 in just the 7 weeks it made the BB 200 soundscan chart, it has peaked at #28 on the BB200 and sold 115,000 in SPS copies.

clock ha