[Stitches.]

Originally posted by Ryuuchan_X

Let me just say the Little Monsters are getting exactly what they deserve for praising this new "authentic" Gaga. This is not authentic, it's basic and BORING. It's so sad to see her decline like this. I loved Gaga when she was innovating pop music with her amazing videos and looks. That was truly unique and authentic.

I will not stan for this basic trash.

the meltdowns already. PI all over again

[PersonalJesus]

what were you guys expecting? A breakdown choreograph with gays in high heels while she pukes on them and then she opens the gift and eats the rosary.

[Marioland]

Originally posted by Stitches.

the meltdowns already. PI all over again

Pi was actually a decent video ... Not great but this mess is unbearable!

[Cruel World]

This is underwhelming, the song is fantastic tho and always makes me cry, love the melody so much. the song deserved a better video.

She looks absolutely beautiful and oh well I'll never leave her anyway I just love this woman too much. Truly monster for life

[Rama]

Originally posted by PersonalJesus

what were you guys expecting? A breakdown choreograph with gays in high heels while she pukes on them and then she opens the gift and eats the rosary.

No. Something like Kiss It Better would be perfect. Boring and safe, sure, but pleasant to see


I REFUSE to believe she can't deliver that

[Reinvention]

Originally posted by PersonalJesus

what were you guys expecting? A breakdown choreograph with gays in high heels while she pukes on them and then she opens the gift and eats the rosary.

We were expecting to see something of her outside looking beautiful and elegant, simply singing the song. Half of her performances of this song would make for a more interesting music video. This is just such a bad, pointless combination of shots. If she had even put half as much effort in as Katy did for "Rise" it'd be fine.

[That Britney Face]

I know Gaga can balance her pop fan side and her GP side. She just has to want to do it, but clearly she wants to get acclaim again. I get it.

I fear we'll never see "fierce" Gaga again.

[Grown K]

Originally posted by romonster

It's a cute video and it works for the song.

This is yet another case of people having unrealistic expectations from her in 2016 when it should have been obvious since Perfect Illusion that the video would have looked something like this.

Nothing is worse than The Edge Of Glory in 2011 - that video came RIGHT AFTER Judas and at the peak of her career.

As an artist who always presented herself as creative and innovative, this music video is pure trashy garbage ****.
She's not my family, she's not my friend, I don't have to keep my expectations low and try to support her. I'm the one that buys her products so if she doesn't serve what she's supposed to, she's not getting my coins.
This is not a cute video. Eh Eh was a cute video.

[RichGirlPlanet]

Absolutely awful.

[Marioland]

Originally posted by Reinvention

We were expecting to see something of her outside looking beautiful and elegant, simply singing the song. Half of her performances of this song would make for a more interesting music video. This is just such a bad, pointless combination of shots. If she had even put half as much effort in as Katy did for "Rise" it'd be fine.

Exactly! Rise is a visual masterpiece compared to this..... AND I FREAKING HATE KATY PERRY SO MUCH!

[Leptine]

I like the meaning, but I can't say that I'm snatched or slayed, I was expecting something better, still simple but better done with more different scenes.

[J a y]

I know what my fans want.



Great idea to reuse the SNL setting, and the editing (I assume by Paul) is very well done.

I like that she switched the narrative from Taylor to Natali. Works with the 'daughter, sister' concept of Joanne.

[Roberto]

I don't understand the video, I swear I could enjoy it more if I knew what is this about.

[Starburst]

Cute.

[AlphaOmega]

[Ryuuchan_X]

Originally posted by Grown K

As an artist who always presented herself as creative and innovative, this music video is pure trashy garbage ****.
She's not my family, she's not my friend, I don't have to keep my expectations low and try to support her. I'm the one that buys her products so if she doesn't serve what she's supposed to, she's not getting my coins.
This is not a cute video. Eh Eh was a cute video.

THANK YOU. I'm so sick of Little Monsters praising mediocrity. I know Gaga is capable of so much more than this.

[Roberto]

Tbh, this will try hard to get the 50M views.

[Brite Lites ☆]

The meltdowns here
Cute concept.

[Dean Winchester]

She's so focused on people seeing her as a "real musician" that she's forgetting that she's also a visual artist. You can be a real musician and be a visual artist. It's not mutually exclusive.

[Pikachoo]

I don't care that the video is simple... Hello was a simple yet effective video. Stay was a ballad but effective.. this was just cringe worthy. A-Yo will hve a good mv though i'm sure of it