Idk how y'all expected the MC score to be ridiculously high anyway. The album is Gaga's best, most cohesive and enjoyable work yet (in my opinion) but that being said, looking at it totally unbiased, it's a a solid album, there's no arguments there. The production, on point, lyrics, on point, vocals, on point. That doesn't mean people reviewing it are gonna love it though because if you look at albums that do get high scores, they're usually sort of breaking the mould, in some way either sonically or lyrically or in relation to subject matter, there's something new and fresh being done. So this is why you can see why Beyoncé's lemonade did so well critically, she took on a different subject matter. Something so political and close to her. Whereas Adele's album was also very good, she just didn't write about anything groundbreaking and her sound stayed pretty much the same as her other records. So Gagas not going to get absolutely glowing reviews. Joanne is still fantastic however
I see it in the end getting 70-75