[PalorPorom]

Originally posted by Halien4Life

oh my GOD, the MESS

the 1st rate ever to host a girl-groups stans vs. bg stans vs everyone else



HERE 4 iT

I see male artists peaking around the forties placements. It won't be a competition for long.

[Chemist]

Originally posted by Kxvk

This is going to be a mess.

Will it be just title tracks or will everything be fair game?

I don't know we will have to make the rules I guess. Also max how many songs per artist per person

[Wotamin]

Here for my faves to win again
BEG won once and then SHINee, like YG says - who's next?

[Kxvk]

Originally posted by Wotamin

Here for my faves to win again
BEG won once and then SHINee, like YG says - who's next?

Airplane COMING for that top spot if album cuts are in.

[Halien4Life]

can't we wait for BLACPINK to have more than 2 songs?

[Guero]

Originally posted by Halien4Life

can't we wait for BLACPINK to have more than 2 songs?

let's just make sure those two songs appear in the top 10.

[Kxvk]

Originally posted by Chemist

I don't know we will have to make the rules I guess. Also max how many songs per artist per person

5 songs per artist per person imo.

[Selenurr]

What rating system are you gonna use?

I would include album tracks. Idk know if that's too messy though.

[KORDEI]

so basically, this is a girl group rate?

[Halien4Life]

we should keep it to singles

album tracks would be so messy and fans tend to be delusional about certain album tracks lol

[Kxvk]

Yeah it should be title tracks/singles only.

[Kosmo]

On 2nd thought I feel like non-title songs are pointless since there's no way an album track's gonna win anyway. I can vote for some flop Monsta X sing that no one else knows when I could use those points to give to someone else.

Unless we're willing to take a risk and have a BG rate 2.0 situation with a winner coming in 2nd cause we wanted a personal favourite to have a shot at that #100 position

[8thPrince]

Originally posted by Kxvk

Airplane COMING for that top spot if album cuts are in.

Airplane already won the f(x) discog rate


------------------

I agree with keeping it to singles, maybe we could do an album track rate separately like shic wanted to do

[Kosmo]

Originally posted by 8thPrince

I agree with keeping it to singles, maybe we could do an album track rate separately like shic wanted to do

That was me



But I agree, the non-singles should have a separate rate with a voting system like the BG rate with everyone having to listen to all the songs.

[Chemist]

Ok but who wants to host it?

[BlazingLovatic]

How are we gonna cut it down to 5 songs per group?

[jongshic]

I'd volunteer and use RafaelBuzz as my graphics slave but I have school
& the thread awards to start working on soon

[apex]

I need to get my Genie campaign materials ready

[PalorPorom]

Originally posted by BlazingLovatic

How are we gonna cut it down to 5 songs per group?

Can that group's stans convene and agree on representative songs? That way I can make sure Roly Poly stays in the past where it belongs.

[M A R C]

Lay solo album in October.