[Ecstasy]

Originally posted by conatus

This is dumb, some of us love both.

And some of us, like Ecstasy, have bad taste.

Oh I put up with a lot of crap from you. The Janitor songs, the random Moo tracks playing in the night, the boring pedestrian cheesy 80s/70s album tracks, the unforgivable underappreciation of Godney but I am not buckling on this. Lemonade is trash and so is E MO TION. GET IT THROUGH YOUR HEAD

[RihannasVeryOwn]

Originally posted by conatus

All his albums are so good. I need people to stop pretending Coastal Grooves isn't a masterpiece though.

i havent listened to much of Coastal Grooves except Forget It which I love, getting back into it rn

[Robyn]

Originally posted by alkralkra

Lemonade is the best album of the decade

Not even her best album this decade

[collin]

What's this masterpiece. Conatus (going out on a limb here) and Tom, gather.

[Clump]

E•MO•TION is at least 78 x better than Lemonade. This is not up for debate.

[Lucas32]

Lemonade actually grew on me slightly over time. I really like Hold up now.

Know that I kept it sexy, and know I kept it fun
There's something that I'm missing, maybe my head for one

This is such a clever line.

[DoubleDutchess]

Originally posted by Sunshine.

There's nothing objective that would suggest Lem' is a bad album. The writing is tight, the themes are important, the production is clean, the melodies are catchy, the vocals are magnificent, the songs are diverse, and best of all it's a story. Everyone loves a story.

It's objectively a good album.

But I could see why it might challenge the “E•MO•TION should have won AOTY" crowd on ATRL.

[Tom Vercetti]

Lemonade isn't even Album Of The Year

But it's good.

[RihannasVeryOwn]

Lemonade is boring, I havent had any impulse to listen to it since I watched the film the day it came out.
EMOTION is genuinely a perfect pop album and thats a fact

[conatus]

Originally posted by Sunshine.

I love Emotion too. But some peoples taste here doesn't go beyond sugary pop music.

That's true, I suppose.

Originally posted by Ecstasy

Oh I put up with a lot of crap from you. The Janitor songs, the random Moo tracks playing in the night, the boring pedestrian cheesy 80s/70s album tracks, the unforgivable underappreciation of Godney but I am not buckling on this. Lemonade is trash and so is E MO TION. GET IT THROUGH YOUR HEAD

Someone's sleeping on the porch tonight.

Originally posted by RihannasVeryOwn

i havent listened to much of Coastal Grooves except Forget It which I love, getting back into it rn

The Complete Knock is at least top 3 in his discog. AT LEAST.

[NX127]

Pray You Catch Me: 4/10
Hold Up: 4/10
Don't Hurt Yourself: 5/10
Sorry: 5/10
6 Inch: 5/10
Daddy Lessons: 0/10
Love Drought: 4/10
Sandcastles: 3/10
Forward: 2/10
Freedom: 1/10
All Night: 5/10
Formation: Worst song of all time, 0/10

Overall, 4/10 without Formation, 0/10 including Formation.

[Аshanti]

Formation is not the worst song of all time. I mean, Fading exists, Skin exists, Right Now (feat. David Guetta) exists and the list goes on

[Lucas32]

Although Formation & Sorry are still easily the worst songs she's released IASF or maybe even B'Day.

[conatus]

Originally posted by Аshanti

Formation is not the worst song of all time. I mean, Fading exists, Skin exists, Right Now (feat. David Guetta) exists and the list goes on

You had me with you until you said Skin.

Fading and Right Now are, without a doubt, worse than Formation though, as are a lot of things because Formation is a 10/10.

[Sunshine.]

collin is wrong. lol

She had 3 singles on Billboard Top 20.

[Sunshine.]

Formation is one of her best songs. All one needs to do is watch her tour opening.

One of the best of all time.

[RihannasVeryOwn]

Skin being worse than anything and I didnt think I could ever come across someone with worse taste than RRN1

[Clump]

Originally posted by NX127

Pray You Catch Me: 4/10
Hold Up: 4/10
Don't Hurt Yourself: 5/10
Sorry: 5/10
6 Inch: 5/10
Daddy Lessons: 0/10
Love Drought: 4/10
Sandcastles: 3/10
Forward: 2/10
Freedom: 1/10
All Night: 5/10
Formation: Worst song of all time, 0/10

Overall, 4/10 without Formation, 0/10 including Formation.

Seems very fair to me! I agree with these ratings.

Meanwhile, every song on E•MO•TION is 10/10.

[Аshanti]

Originally posted by conatus

You had me with you until you said Skin.

Fading and Right Now are, without a doubt, worse than Formation though, as are a lot of things because Formation is a 10/10.

Are you implying that Skin is a 11/10? Cause it's just wrong.

[Tom Vercetti]

@ Skin being in "worst"