[SilencePlease]

Mess at you including Bey but not Madonna/Britney/Katy/Rihanna.

[Jet]

Originally posted by Legacy

How? The guy sold 100 millions albums, made rap global, almost died and came back with a album that didn't do well for his standards and came back again next year with 2 smash hits and an album that sold millions of copies . Everybody knows him. I mean, ifBeyoncé is a legend then he is.

!!

[Travis Bickle]

Originally posted by dabunique

u kno u did forget the most successful female artist of all time but i kno u can't stand ha so u do it to get us mad lol
not workin boo, try harder

The fact that it's not the first time making this thread

[Daydream]

Originally posted by Travis Bickle

The fact that it's not the first time making this thread

Please link me to where I have made this thread before because I'm 100% certain I have not, Travis Bickle.

[Auburn]

Originally posted by Jet

Well if we go by real numbers Beyonce wins and still has lasted longer than Britney so that's a moot point.

"real numbers"

I'm sorry sweetie but DC+Beyoncé doesn't count.

Britney has one flop era and suddenly she's over, was Bey's career over after 4?

We'll see when Make Me outpeaks everything Bey has done since IASF with the exception of Drunk In Love

[A$APRoman]

Originally posted by Daydream

These are the ones we have left:

Mariah Carey
Stevie Wonder
Paul McCartney
Barbra Streisand
George Michael
Snoop Dogg
Diana Ross
Dolly Parton
Janet Jackson
Bruce Springsteen
Kanye West
Tina Turner
R. Kelly
Elton John
Céline Dion
Cher
Smokey Robinson
Bob Dylan
Beyoncé
Aretha Franklin
Tony Bennett
Lady Gaga
Slash
Madonna
Jay-Z

Don't think I missed anyone important.

fixedT

[SebaMonster]

Madonna.

[mdnazn]

there are way more than that, like hundreds more

but this is ATRL, so I am not even going to bother

[Planet Mars]

Originally posted by Legacy

How? The guy sold 100 millions albums, made rap global, almost died and came back with a album that didn't do well for his standards and came back again next year with 2 smash hits and an album that sold millions of copies . Everybody knows him. I mean, ifBeyoncé is a legend then he is.

I've heard it all, Eminem made rap global

[Ryann]

The Madonna and Kylie shade in the OP

[ultraviolento]

first requisition to be a legend:

https://rockhall.com/inductees/

if your fave is not there, then there's a 90% of chance he/she isn't a real respected acclaimed influential legend (mariah, celine and whitney are not there and they're not legends for example)

[Ricky Wilson]

at Britney being mentioned

Can only think of Madonna and Beyoncé right now

[Jet]

Originally posted by Auburn

"real numbers"

I'm sorry sweetie but DC+Beyoncé doesn't count.

Britney has one flop era and suddenly she's over, was Bey's career over after 4?

We'll see when Make Me outpeaks everything Bey has done since IASF with the exception of Drunk In Love

Nowhere did I mention DC lol.

And Britney has been flopping albums-wise since 2011. Even 4 managed to sell 3 million WW with no hits while FF only managed to sell 1 million with 3 top 10's! I won't entertain the last part cuz it's pure delusion

----

Anyways, Britney isn't a legend but I think Eminem and Madonna at least deserve a mention

[Daydream]

Originally posted by ultraviolento

mariah, celine and whitney are not there and they're not legends

Goodbyeeeeeee! Now this is the most ludicrous thing mentioned in this entire thread.

[Ricky Wilson]

Originally posted by Auburn

"real numbers"

I'm sorry sweetie but DC+Beyoncé doesn't count.

Britney has one flop era and suddenly she's over, was Bey's career over after 4?

We'll see when Make Me outpeaks everything Bey has done since IASF with the exception of Drunk In Love

DC adds up to Beyoncé's legacy, not DC's fault that Britney couldn't stay relevant for 2 decades

And Beyoncé has yet to bomb as hard as Britney did with BJ or Pretty Girls, despite having been around longer

[FreeAsMyWeave]

One. Nadine Coyle.

[Nemo]

Originally posted by Eternium

And you got the damn nerve to leave Britney and Madonna off of there?

Girl that's the only reason they made this thread they literally made one like less than a week ago with the same sole intention. Cringeee

[Daydream]

Where is the other thread I've made? I want to know.

[Travis Bickle]

Originally posted by Travis Bickle

You can remain mad that your favorite is NEVER reaching Madonna's legend status


Rock and Roll Hall of Fame


UK Music Hall Of Fame

Plus



First female to get their own Collector’s Edition

[ultraviolento]

madonna is inducted into the rock and roll hall of fame and received several nominations to the songwriters hof (because you know, she's actually a respected songwriter in the real world, unlike many so called great songwriters who are only respected and acclaimed within this internet forum), so she's definitely a legend. not everybody has that.