[Erebos]

This is gving some ANTI vibes What a messy era already

[CakeLike]

Originally posted by HausofNiko

elton said it was like you and i / bad romance

In that case good riddance, you and i is trash and they already tried to replicate bad romance and it was basically a carbon copy.

Lemme pin all my hopes onto Mark Ronson, i know he won't disappoint.

[joe71941]

I want 10-11 or 12 songs max but really, really good. No deluxe, no nothing.

[GypsyLife]

Originally posted by HausofNiko

So is all the work from 2015 just gone? she better have at least 1-2 songs by redone, especially if they were bad romance / you and i quality

Well Elton said they were of that quality, that's it. He didn't say if those were the ones she made with Red1 or by herself or even with Mark.

[Giorgoc]

Originally posted by Bang Up

I totally get what you mean and I would feel the same way if I didn't have KPOP to fill my dance fix.

For the time being, Meghan is serving that purpose. I love both NO and Me Too, though they obviously cannot compare to Gaga's greatness.

I do get that Gaga has to evolve and change her sound, (she's a grown ass woman by now) but I just can't picture a Tour with no EDM. What's gonna happen to her old hits? Is she gonna remake them to fit her new sound? Is she gonna ditch them?

I'm also not liking her new image. I love the way she looks, probably better than ever, but the "I love everything and everyone" persona is a far cry from the bad bitch I loved during TFM and BTW.

[Bang Up]

Originally posted by Optimus

Hah. People did not dislike Judas because of its production, they hated it because of lyrics. And who wrote them? Gaga herself. Also, lets not forget that Judas is the most viewed video from the Btw era+ it was a semi hit in Europe. And Gaga has not been a factor there since it.

RedOne had nothing to do with the 'Judas' video. Guess who wrote the treatment. Ms. Gaga herself.

You saying they hated it because of the lyrics yet you don't have any proof of that. Many hit songs have horrible lyrics but are played because the beat is good. If the production was good, it would've been played and become a hit regardless.

RedOne loses again. Hi

[Optimus]

Originally posted by HausofNiko

I guess if you look at it this way...

RedOne's last #1 - 2009
Mark Ronson's last #1 - 2015 (song of the decade)

I trust him i guess

Zedd won a Grammy for Clarity and then G.U.Y happened. Your point?

[Opacho]

Originally posted by Optimus

Hah. People did not dislike Judas because of its production, they hated it because of lyrics. And who wrote them? Gaga herself. Also, lets not forget that Judas is the most viewed video from the Btw era+ it was a semi hit in Europe. And Gaga has not been a factor there since it.

WHAT DID I SAY

Madonna's Like A Prayer is about blow jobs and in the video she burns crosses. It caused huge controversy, only it's actually a good song so it did well. It went #1 What's Judas' excuse? It was just too fast and Bad Romance 2.0. and people didn't eat the production. It was not radio friendly at ALL. RedOne's fault

[Gladion]

Originally posted by Summer Boy

also wtf he said he didn't like ARTPOP when he did NOT heard Gypsy. How can you say you don't like an album when you haven't even heard it in full?

I think he meant he didn't hear it finished before it was done for the album

[romonster]

Originally posted by Opacho

That's not how this works. She 's probably going to use those songs later in the future.At this point there's no doubt in my mind she changed the whole sound of the album. It's clearly not a dance oriented album BUT, if those songs are good as he says she might wanna save them for future use. Especially the supposed 'lead'.

She keeps saying how she has albums and albums of finished unreleased material that she keeps playing around her friends so I don't know but it would be nice if we actually got to hear them at some point
Yeah, the sound of the album definitely changed the second she started working with Mark Ronson in London

[GypsyLife]

I just remembered reading on PopJustice months ago (by Mindtrappa actually) that Gaga and RedOne didn't hit it off while recording and set up a 2nd meeting to give it another try.
Reading what RedOne said about working with her I guess his information was right

[Bang Up]

Originally posted by Giorgoc

For the time being, Meghan is serving that purpose. I love both NO and Me Too, though they obviously cannot compare to Gaga's greatness.

I do get that Gaga has to evolve and change her sound, (she's a grown ass woman by now) but I just can't picture a Tour with no EDM. What's gonna happen to her old hits? Is she gonna remake them to fit her new sound? Is she gonna ditch them?

I'm also not liking her new image. I love the way she looks, probably better than ever, but the "I love everything and everyone" persona is a far cry from the bad bitch I loved during TFM and BTW.

Gaga's always been focused on loving everything and everyone. I don't really get this idea that she randomly changed. I mean, that was the whole point of Born This Way. Just like before, she has her moments where she'll speak up and take nobody's ****, but it's never been an all-time thing for her.

And IDK what she'll do with her old music. I doubt she'll scrap it but I'm sure the new music will take priority.

Originally posted by Optimus

Zedd won a Grammy for Clarity and then G.U.Y happened. Your point?

Gaga won a Grammy for 'Poker Face' and then 'Judas' happened. You're right!

[Optimus]

Originally posted by Opacho

WHAT DID I SAY

Madonna's Like A Prayer is about blow jobs and in the video she burns crosses. It caused huge controversy, only it's actually a good song so it did well. It went #1 What's Judas' excuse? It was just too fast and Bad Romance 2.0. and people didn't eat the production. It was not radio friendly at ALL. RedOne's fault

If and ordinary man reads LAP's lyrics how the hell could he tell the song's about blowjobs Its like saying people knew Poker Face was about bisexuality when everyone thought it was about playing ****ing poker

[Opacho]

Originally posted by Bang Up

Gaga won a Grammy for 'Poker Face' and then 'Judas' happened. You're right!

'b-b-but gaga.. l-lyrics... reli-hiiiion. '

[Giorgoc]

Originally posted by Dämon

Fun game. Let me try:

DJWS's last Top 3 hit - 2013
RedOne's last Top 3 hit - 2011

Which Top 3 hit in 2013 are you talking about?

[Dämon]

Originally posted by Giorgoc

Which Top 3 hit in 2013 are you talking about?

Top 4, but the answer remains the same

Anyway! RedOne was scrapped, his material will always sound super dated. Life's good; Life's great. Quality music is coming.

[Giorgoc]

Originally posted by Bang Up

Gaga's always been focused on loving everything and everyone. I don't really get this idea that she randomly changed.

Yeah but the way she's behaved has changed immensely.

She's always loved her fans and her idols but she's taken it to another level. She used to be fierce and fearless while now it feels like she's trying to become America's sweetheart.

It could possibly be that she's in a better state of mind right now, but I don't know... she doesn't feel like a pop icon anymore.

[REALiTi]

Anyway ...

Do we all agree this is the best Lady Gaga has ever looked? The looks and sex she was serving on AHS.

[Optimus]

Originally posted by Bang Up

If the production was good, it would've been played and become a hit regardless.
RedOne loses again. Hi

How the hell would you know that Why wasnt Applause a bigger hit? Do you think that it was the production's fault or the weird not relatable lyrics?

[Matte]

Not y'all debating about ChartTops by producers
I guess it's true that the base recycles the same arguments



Regardless it'd be interesting to hear RedOne tracks. Maybe it was right edit him out because he does catch on trends like Starships, and now the new house sound. But like we always say, his production is different for Gaga... sans Just Dance/Money Honey which pasted onto Evacuate the Dancefloor